WP 3: Flagship Program on Biopolymers

Transkript

WP 3: Flagship Program on Biopolymers
Flagship Biopolymers
WP 3: Flagship Program on
Biopolymers
Jan van Beilen
Yves Poirier
Bill Orts
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
1
Flagship Biopolymers
Plastics in EU (15)
Bioplastics (EU15, 2003)
40,000,000 T/Y
40,000 T/Y (0.1%)
Current market share of bioplastics is very small
Potential for growth is very large
Substitution of 10%
30%
4,000,000 T/Y
12,000,000 T/Y
50 million hectares of agricultural land in EU (25) are set
aside and not required for food production
1 hectare = 2 tons bioplastic
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
2
Flagship Biopolymers
Global mineral oil used for energy
Mineral oil used by chemical industry
Polymers
4’000 MT
300 MT
150 MT
Biopolymers can have a positive impact on dependence
on mineral oil and GHG emission
Biopolymers as the main product or as a secondary
product of biofuels or chemicals from biorefineries
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
3
Flagship Biopolymers
Which biopolymers?
•
•
•
•
•
Polyisoprenoids
Starch-based
Protein-based
Polyhydroxyalkanoates
Other plant biopolymers
• Cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin: Cell wall
• Polyols based on plant oils: Plant oil
• Bioplastics produced by fermentation or chemical
synthesis: PLA, PHAs, PCL, Sorona: SusChem project
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
4
Flagship Biopolymers
General issues
• Biodegradability used as a marketing
tool, but GHG emission and
renewability may become important
drivers
• Applications: mostly (potentially) low
cost, high volume
• Limitations: cost, properties, supplychain
• GMO issues, acceptance
• Fermentation vs in planta
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
5
Flagship Biopolymers
Synthetic and natural rubber
Synthetic:
Plant based:
Polystyrene-butadiene (SBR)
€ 1.30 / kg 2’400’000 T/A
Poly-cis-isoprene (natural rubber)
€ 1.80 / kg
7’000’000 T/A
99% from Hevea brasiliensis
Poly-butadiene (BR)
Poly-chloropropene (CR)
Poly-acrylonitrile-butadiene
Polyisoprene
Many others
Total 10’500’000 T/A
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Poly-trans-isoprene (gutta percha,
balata) and mixtures (chicle)
$ 50-100 / kg
> 3’000 T/A
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
6
Flagship Biopolymers
Natural rubber
• Produced as in 1910
– Labor intensive
– Smallholders and plantations
• Strategic importance
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
- Largely produced in SE-Asia
- No substitute available (tires)
- Rubber plantations are being
replaced by palm oil plantations
- Could be destroyed by South
american leaf blight (SALB)
- Limited R&D efforts on SALB and
rubber synthesis enzymes
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
7
Flagship Biopolymers
Natural rubber: to do
Hevea brasiliensis
– Resistance to South American
Leaf Blight
– Reduce allergenic proteins
… or find alternatives
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
8
Flagship Biopolymers
Natural rubber: to do
Alternative sources
– Guayule: could be grown in
southern USA, perhaps in
mediterranean countries
– Russian dandelion: could be
grown in Europe
– Goldenrod and other potential
NR sources
– Tropical trees other than H.
brasiliensis
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
9
Flagship Biopolymers
Natural rubber: to do
Alternative sources
– Guayule: could be grown in
southern USA, perhaps in
mediterranean countries
– Russian dandelion: could be
grown in Europe
– Goldenrod and other potential
NR sources
– Tropical trees other than H.
brasiliensis
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
10
Flagship Biopolymers
Natural rubber: to do
Alternative sources
– Guayule: could be grown in
southern USA, perhaps in
mediterranean countries
– Russian dandelion: could be
grown in Europe
– Goldenrod and other potential
NR sources
– Tropical trees other than H.
brasiliensis
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
11
Flagship Biopolymers
Starch
•
57’000’000 T/A, € 0.30 per kg
•
20-30% amylose, 70-80% amylopectin
• Corn, wheat, potato, cassava, rice
• Many variants: high amylose, no
amylose, high phosphate, low MW,
“starch-enhanced”
• Chemical, mechanical, thermal,
blending treatments
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
12
Flagship Biopolymers
Starch-based bioplastics
Production capacity
•
•
•
•
Novamont: 20’000 T/A
Rodenburg Biopolymers:
36’000 T/A
National Starch Company:
20’000 T/A
BIOP: 10’000 T/A
Biotec: 2’000 T/A
•
•
Sales 25’000 T/A (2001)
€ 1.00 to € 5.00 / kg
•
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
13
Flagship Biopolymers
Starch-based plastics: issues
• Thermoplastic materials resulting from the processing
of native starch
– Thermal: gelatinization, destructurization
– Chemical: esters, ethers, crosslinking, depolymerization
– Mechanical: extrusion with fillers, additives, plasticisers
(glycerol, polyvinylalcohol, ethyleneglycol)
– Blending: polycaprolactone, PHA, cellulose acetate
• “Everything has been tried” (and patented)!
• But, new renewable polymers available for blending,
new plasticisers, new starch variants
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
14
Flagship Biopolymers
Protein biopolymers
• Agricultural bulk protein
streams
– Zein (4% of corn dw):
Vicara (2’200 T/A, 1954)
– Soy protein (38-45% of
soy dw): 1930’s, 40’s
– Wheat gluten (cheap)
• Repetitive-unit proteins
– Silk, elastin, adhesin,
synthetic sequences
• Non-ribosomally
produced polypeptides:
– Polyasparate, polylysine
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
15
Flagship Biopolymers
Protein biopolymers: issues
•
Potentially huge amounts of protein coproducts from biofuels production
(zein, soy and potato protein, gluten)
•
Heterologous production of silk,
adhesin, synthetic sequences,
cyanophycin:
Plants vs fermentation ?
•
In GMO plants: high level, effects on
hosts, post-harvest stability, extraction,
processing - need R&D
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
16
Flagship Biopolymers
Polyhydroxyalkanoates
•
•
•
•
PHB: poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (C4)
PHBV: PHB-co-valerate (C4-C5)
PHBH: PHB-co-hexanoate (C4-C6)
mclPHA: β-hydroxyalkanoates (C6-C16)
• Production by fermentation
–
–
–
–
–
Up to 85 % of cell dry weight
Control over composition
Continuous production
Established down-stream processing
Projected cost: € 2 / kg
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
17
Flagship Biopolymers
Polyhydroxyalkanoates: issues
• Production in recombinant plants
– Potentially cheaper, better CO2-balance
– Great effort required to get to significant
levels
– Down-stream processing
– Stability of polyester after harvest
• Current status
– 40% PHB in leaf tissue (but only 8-10%
without effects on growth)
– Metabolix develops production in
Switchgrass
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
18
Flagship Biopolymers
Biopolymers: fermentation & chemical
• Polylactic acid (PLA)
– 150’000 T/A capacity (mainly Cargill, many small-scale
producers)
• Polyhydroxyalkanoates
– 50’000 T/A planned by Metabolix / ADM
– Nodax, P&G, Kaneka
• Polyesters
–
–
–
–
Eastar: butanediol / succinate / terephthalate copolymers
Sorona: propanediol / terephthalate copolymer
Bionolle: butanediol / succinate / adipate copolymers
Ecoflex: butanediol / adipate / terephthalate copolymers
All indirectly (partially) made from sugars or oils
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
19
Flagship Biopolymers
Questions
What is the role of agriculture and plant biotechnology in…
•
Ensuring constant supply of high quality natural rubber, one
of the most important biopolymer produced from plants
•
Make better use of starch as a source of valuable biopolymer
•
Taking advantage of protein co-product streams (gluten, zein,
soy protein, recombinant?) that will become much more
important with biofuels
•
Production of PHAs, specialty proteins and other polymers
that can also be produced by fermentation technology
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
20
Flagship Biopolymers
Breakout group on bipolymer flagship
Room Dorskampzaal I
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
21
Flagship Biopolymers
More issues
• Economics of GMOs:
does it pay to create and
introduce GMO plants for
bioplastics
• Selling points:
biodegradability and
GMO don’t mix well
• Disposal: burning may be
the best solution, but
doesn’t appeal to
customers
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
22
Flagship Biopolymers
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
23
Flagship Biopolymers
Starch-based plastics: issues
• Thermoplastic materials resulting from the processing
of native starch
– Thermal: gelatinization, destructurization
– Chemical: esters, ethers, crosslinking, depolymerization
– Mechanical: extrusion with fillers, additives, plasticisers
(glycerol, polyvinylalcohol, ethyleneglycol)
– Blending: with polycaprolactone, PHA, cellulose acetate
QuickTime™ and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Wageningen, May 22, 2006
Jan van Beilen,Yves Poirier
24