+$00$ 9 35
Transkript
+$00$ 9 35
%KLNNKX.XVDODQDQGD $%+,'+$00$935$;, StUXþNDSURSRNURþLOpPHGLWXMtFt]DORåHQiQDSHNODGX a páli textu, který v devátém století po Buddhovi sepsal %KLNNKX%XGGKDGDWWD $%+,'+$00$ 6$*$+$ *$17+$ pod názvem 5*3À5*3$ 9,%+À*$ .RQWH[WSUXÍN\ $EKLGKDPPD73LDNDÇHVN\C6RXERUY\ ©QDXN\AMHWRX]HW §ÇVW§EXGGKLVWLFN£KRNQRQX7L73LDND 7URM7VRXERU NWHU REVDKXMH ]NODGQ§ PDWLFH P½WLN½ ] QLFK O]H SULQFLSLOQÕ RGYRGLW YHFKQ\ RVWDWQ§ ÇVWL %XGGKRY\ QDXN\ =NODGQ§ YÕGÕQ§ DEKLGKDPP\ MH ÇHVN\ VKUQXWR Y XÇHEQLFL 0 )U·ED 3V\FKRORJLH ]YOGQ© LYRWD 7 $SOLNDFH PHWRG\ DEKLGKDPPD 1DNODGDWHOVWY§ 0DVDU\NRY\ XQLYHU]LW\ %UQR 9 XYHGHQ£ Y\VRNRNROVN£ XÇHEQLFL VH QDO£]DM§ RGND]\ QD YÕGHFN£ SUFH UHOHYDQWQ§ SUR WHRUHWLFN£ SRFKRSHQ§ EXGGKLVPX W£ MVRX Y Q§ SRGQ\ SRGUREQ£ LQVWUXNFH SUR ]NODGQ§ SRVWXS\ %XGGKRY\PHWRG\PHGLWDFHMHMVRXLQVWUXPHQWOQ§SURGRVDHQ§YHKRYÕGÕQ§DEKLGKDPP\ &HO·NQRQ7LSLDNDY W£QHMVWDU§DQHMSYRGQÕM§GRGQHVQHPÕQÕQ£IRUPÕE\OIRUPXORYQW LVWDOHW SR%XGGKRYLWHG\YHW HW§PVWROHW§S HGQD§POHWRSRÇWHPY MD]\FH3OL6HGPVHWOHWSR%XGGKRYLD SR]GÕML ]DÇDO\ Y]QLNDW W£ S HNODGRY£ YHU]H NQRQX Y 6DQVNUWX ƧQWLQÕ 7LEHWWLQÕ -DSRQWLQÕ DWG 7£PÕ YHFKQ\WH[W\7LSLDN\MVRXQ\Q§GRVWXSQ£LY DQJOLFN£PS HNODGX.DG·S HNODGYDN]NUHVO§ REVDK\DS HGHY§PVWUXNWXU\SYRGQ§FKWH[WFRPRE]YOWÕY S §SDGÕDEKLGKDPP\UXLY·GRSDG QD LQVWUXNFH N PHGLWDFL D S HWY HQ§ P\VOL SURWR MH Y·KRGQ£ ]QW MD]\N 3OL DOHVSRï Y ]NODGHFK ]SURVW HGNRYDQ·FKY XÇHEQLFL0 )U·ED3OL7MD]\NWH[W\NXOWXUD$OEHUW%UQR $EKLGKDPPD76DíJDKD7*DQWKD ÇHVN\ C.QLKD VRXKUQX Y\ © QDXN\A MH ] HMPÕ YEHF SUYQ§ SRVW; NDQRQLFNRX NQLKRX DEKLGKDPPLFN£ OLWHUDWXU\ 'UXKRX MH UR]VKOHM§ NQLKD $EKLGKDPPD7$YDW½UD $SOLNDFH Y\ © QDXN\ RG VWHMQ£KR DXWRUD %KLNNKX %XGGKDGDWW\ NWHU· LO Y SW£P VWROHW§ QDHKR OHWRSRÇWX-HKRPODG§PVRXÇDVQ§NHPE\O%KLNNKX%XGGKDJKRVDNRPSLOWRUVODYQ£9LVXGGKL70DJJD &HVWD ÉLVWRW\ NWHU MH GRGQHV WRX QHMREVKOHM§ S §UXÇNRX XÇLWHO PHGLWDFH D REVDKXMH Y SRVOHGQ§FK GHY§WLNDSLWROFKWHRUHWLFN·S HKOHGDEKLGKDPP\9HGYDQFW£PVWROHW§QDHKROHWRSRÇWXNRPSRQRYDO %KLNNKX $QXUXGGKD WH[W $EKLGKDPPD7$WWKD76DíJDKD 6RXKUQ Y¹]QDP Y\ © QDXN\ MHQ MH SUR VRXGRE£ XÇHQFH DVL W§P QHMX§YDQÕM§P NRPSHQGLHP DEKLGKDPP\ = KOHGLVND SUDNWLFN£KR XLW§ SUR PHGLWDFL D S HWY HQ§ P\VOL QHPH YDN GQ ] WÕFKWR NQLK NRQNXURYDW WH[WP FWLKRGQ£KR %KLNNKX%XGGKDGDWW\ © 2000%KLNNKX.XVDODQDQGD'KDPPáráma Brno i %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD $EKLGKDPPDYSUD[L $EKLGKDPPD76DíJDKD7*DQWKD GY NRPSOHWQ§ SRMPRYRX Y·EDYX SUR SUD[L PHGLWDFH Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX VDWLSDK½QD7YLSDVVDQ½ 0PH ]GH V\VWHPDWLFN\ SRGDQ£ PDWLFH DQDO·]\ NWHU£ %XGGKD SRXLO YH VY·FK W HFK SURSRNURÇLORXPHGLWDFLQHMGOHLWÕM§FKSURPOXYFK=NODGQ§PDWLFHFHO£VY£ QDXN\SRGDO%XGGKDYHVY£YEHFSUYQ§ HÇL'KDPPDFDNNDSSDYDWWDQD76XWWDSOLWH[WDLQWHUOLQHUQ§ ÇHVN· S HNODG Y 3OL 7 MD]\N WH[W\ NXOWXUD .RPSOHWQ§ LQVWUXNFL PHGLWDFH Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX GDO %XGGKD Y HÇL 0DK½76DWLSDK½QD76XWWD ÇHVN· S HNODG VSROX V SRGUREQRX LQVWUXNF§ Y NQL]H 0DKVL 6D\DG0HGLWDFHY ©PDYRVWLDYKOHGX6WUDWRV3UDKD$QDO·]XVORHNP\VOLMDNVHY SRNURÇLO£ PHGLWDFL EÕKHP ÇWUQFWLGHQQ§KR LQWHQ]LYQ§KR ]VHGX Y\VN\WXM§ X RE]YOWÕ QDGDQ·FK PHGLWXM§F§FK VÁULSXWWREKLNNKDYHDÑÑKDPÁVDåDQXSDGDGKDPPD YLSDVVDQDåYLSDVVDWL__ XYHGO%XGGKDY HÇL$QXS½GD76XWWD]HNWHU£FLWXMLQVOHGXM§F§SDVHV GRVORYQ·PS HNODGHP G6ULSXWWDEKLNNKRY£SOPÕV§FHPHGLWDFLYKOHGXGRY·VN\WXMHGQRWOLY·FKMHYSURYGÕO LGKDEKLNNKDYHVÁULSXWWRYLYLFF HYDNÁPHKLYLYLFFDDNXVDOHKLGKDPPHKL_ =GHEKLNNKRY£6ULSXWWD]FHODRGORXÇHQRGVP\VOQRVWLRGORXÇHQRG]KRXEQ·FKMHY>S LWRP@ VDYLWWDNDåVDYLFÁUDåYLYHNDMDåSëWLVXNKDå SRM§PQ§PDUR]OLRYQ§PGRSURY]HQ£KR]RGORXÇHQ§]UR]HQ£KRQDGHQ§DWÕVW§>REVDKXM§F§KR@ SD#KDPDåMKÁQDåXSDVDPSDMMDYLKDUDWL__ SUYQ§KRSRKURXHQ§GRVKQXYSRE·YDO \HFDSD#KDPHMKÁQHGKDPPÁYLWWDNRFDYLFÁURFDSëWLFDVXNKD± FD $W\WRSURSUYQ§SRKURXHQ§>FKDUDNWHULVWLFN£@MHY\SRM§PQ§UR]OLRYQ§QDGHQ§WÕVW§ FLWWHNDJJDWÁFD_SKDVVRYHGDQÁVD±±ÁFHWDQÁFLWWDåFKDQGR DMHGQRYUFKRORYRVWLP\VOL>MDNRL@NRQWDNWF§WÕQ§YQ§PQ§]PÕU>]REUD]XM§F§@P\VOS Q§ DGKLPRNNKRYëUL\DåVDWLXSHNNKÁPDQDVLNÁUR_W\ÁVVDGKDPPÁYLGLWÁXSSDMMDQWL_ UR]KRGQXW§´VLO§Y§PDYRVWY\YHQRVWSR]RUQRVW<YHFKQ\W\WRMHY\SR]QYDOMDNY]QLNDM§ YLGLWÁXSD##KDKDQWL_YLGLWÁDEEKDWWKDåJDFFKDQWL__VRHYDåSDMÁQÁWL_HYDå NLUDPHGKDPPÁDKXWYÁVDPEKRQWL_KXWYÁSD#LYHQWëWL__ SR]QYDOMDNWUYDM§SR]QYDOMDNGR]PL]HQ§RGFK]HM§7DNWRPXSRUR]XPÕOMDN RSUDYGXMHY\MHQHE\O\QDVWYDM§MHE\O\VH]WUFHM§G SXQDFDSDUDåEKLNNKDYHVÁULSXWWRVDEEDVRU+SD VD±±ÁQDåVDPDWLNNDPÁ_ $QDY§FEKLNNKRY£6ULSXWWDYHFKQRYQ§PQ§WYDUS HNRQDO SD#LJKD VD±±ÁQDåDWWKDJDPÁ_QÁQDWWD VD±±ÁQDåDPDQDVLNÁUÁ_ YQ§PQ§Y·VOHGN]DQHFKDOYQ§PQ§U]QRURGRVWLVLS HVWDOY§PDW>QDÇHVLXYÕGRPLOH@ DQDQWRÁNÁVRWLÁNÁVÁQD±F Á\DWDQDåXSDVDPSDMMDYLKDUDWL__ QHNRQHÇQ·MHSURVWRU>DWDNWR@REODVWQHNRQHÇQRVWLSURVWRUXGRVKQXYSRE·YDOG SXQDFDSDUDåEKLNNKDYHVÁULSXWWRVDEEDVRQHYDVD±±ÁQÁVD±±ÁQ Á\DWDQDå $QDY§FEKLNNKRY£6ULSXWWDYHNHURXREODVWDQL;YQ§PQ§;DQL;QHYQ§PQ§ VDPDWLNNDPD_VD±±Á YHGD\LWD QLURGKDåXSDVDPSDMMDYLKDUDWL__SD±±Á\D S HNRQDOYQ§PQ§DF§WÕQ§]QLNGRVKQXYSRE·YDO>$]HVWDQRYLWÕWRKRGRVDHQ§@PRXG H FDVVDGLVYÁÁVDYÁSDULNNKëQÁKRQWL__VRWÁ\DVDPÁSDWWL\ÁVDWRYX##KDKDWL__ WRWRYLGÕO>ǧP@YOLY\]QLÇHQ\E\O\= WRKRWRGRVDHQ§Y§PDYÕY\VWRXSLOG 1FYLNWÕFKWRSRVWXSSRNURÇLO£PHGLWDFHSURE§KQD]VHGHFKWUDGLFH{\XNXVDODMHRUJDQL]XMH Dhammáráma – MBNF Zelný trh 12 60200 Brno ii %KLNNKX%XGGKDGDWWD $%+,'+$00$ 6$*$+$ *$17+$ 5*3À5*3$ 9,%+À*$ QDPRWDVVDEKDJDYDWRDUDKDWRVDPP VDPEXGGKDVVD 3R]GUDYMHPXY]QHHQ£PXRSURWÕQ£PXSUDYÕ]FHODSUREX]HQ£PX >7KXWL YDFDQD &KYDOR]SÛY @ v U+SÁU+SD YLGXåEXGGKDåU+SÁU+S ÁWLJDåPXQLå QDPDVVLWYÁSDYDNNKÁPLU+SÁU+SD YLEKÁJDWDå__ %XGGKRYL]QDOFLWÕOHVQ£KRDQHWÕOHVQ£KRPXGUFL>WRWRRERMHG@WUDQVFHQGXM§F§PX QHMSUYHY]GP´FWXQDÇH Y\VYÕWO§PDQDO·]XWÕOHVQ£KRDQHWÕOHVQ£KR &KYDOR]SÕYSRVLOXMHPRWLYDFLNWHURXS LUHFLWRYQ§QDPRWDVVDEKDJDYDWR WÕOHVQÕVWYU]XMHPHDNWHP ´NORQ\VHVHSMDW·PDUXNDPDS LÇHPVLXYÕGRPXMHPH´ÇHOVY£KRMHGQQ§ >5* 3$9,%+À*$ $QDO½]DWÛOHVQ©KR @ v U+SÁU+SDYLEKÁJDQWL_HWWKDWÁYDU+SDQWL__ 9DQDO·]HWÕOHVQ£KRDQHWÕOHVQ£KR>S LPHGLWDFLY§PDYRVWL@]QDPHQWÕOHVQ£WRWR >%K+WD U+SDå (OHPHQWRY¡WÛOHVQRVW @ SD#KDYë GKÁWX WHMR GKÁWX ÁSR GKÁWX YÁ\R GKÁWX HOHPHQW]HPÕ>SHYQRVW@ HOHPHQWYRG\>VRXGUQRVW@ >8SÁGÁ U+SDå =¡YLVO¡WÛOHVQRVW @ v HOHPHQWRKQÕ>WHSORWD@ HOHPHQWY]GXFKX>SRK\E@ FDNNKX GKÁWX U+SD GKÁWX VRWD GKÁWX VDGGD GKÁWX HOHPHQW]UDN HOHPHQWVOXFK JKÁD GKÁWX HOHPHQWÇLFK MLYKÁ GKÁWX HOHPHQWMD]\N>FKXRY·RUJQ@ NÁ\D GKÁWX HOHPHQWKPDW HOHPHQWWYDU>DEDUYD@ HOHPHQW]YXN JDQGKD GKÁWX HOHPHQW SDFK UDVD GKÁWX HOHPHQWFKX SKR##KDEED GKÁWX HOHPHQWGRW\N> EKWD;USD×@ 1 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v LWWK LQGUL\Då §]HQ§HQVNRVW§>VFKRSQRVWSDVLYLW\@ SXULV LQGUL\Då v §]HQ§PXQRVW§>VFKRSQRVWDNWLYLW\@ KDGD\D YDWWKX v HOHPHQWSURVWRU U+SDVVD ODKXWÁ U+SDVVD PXGXWÁ v U+SDVVD VDQWDWL v WUYQ§WÕOHVQRVWL WÕOHVQPUWQRVW U+SDVVD MDUDWÁ VWUQXW§WÕOHVQRVWL U+SDVVD DQLFFDWÁ NDEDOLNÁUD ÁKDUR DWÕOHVQSRWUDYD YDFë YL±±DWWL U+SDVVD XSDFD\R QUVWWÕOHVQRVWL WÕOHVQ·Y·UD] U+SDVVD NDPPD±±DWÁ WÕOHVQSRGGDMQRVW NÁ\D YL±±DWWL VORYQ§Y·UD] WÕOHVQSRK\EOLYRVW §]HQ§ LYRWQRVW§>YLWDOLWD@ VWDQRYLWÕVUGFH>WÕOHVQ£RKQLVNR@ ÁNÁVD GKÁWX MëYLW LQGUL\Då F HWL_ SRP§MLYRVWWÕOHVQRVWL HYDåD##KDYëVDWL YLGKHVXU+SHVX__ v WRMHGRGYDFHWLRVPLGUXK W §GÕQWÕOHVQRVW ÁGLWRSD##KÁ\DFDWXEELGKDåU+SDå_EK+WD U+SDåQÁPD__VHVDå XSÁGÁ U+SDåQÁPD__ 7DSUYQ§ÇWYH LFHWÕOHVQRVWLVHQD]·Y>SUYRWQÕY]QLNO@HOHPHQWRYWÕOHVQRVW7DRVWDWQ§ VHQD]·Y]YLVOWÕOHVQRVW 9 PHWRGLFN£ PHGLWDFL Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX VDWLSDK½QD7YLSDVVDQ½ VH SRX§Y ]SUDYLGOD MDNR Y·FKR]§WHFKQLNDY§PQ§QGHFKXDY·GHFKX½Q½S½QD7VDWLNWHUMH]NODGQRXSUFHNDPPDK½QD QD KODYQ§P QHEROL SULPUQ§P S HGPÕWX PHGLWDFH EK½YDQ½\D7½UDPPDïD 3 LWRP MH MHGQR NGH QGHFK D Y·GHFK SR]RUXMHPH ]GD S L QDUHQ§ QD RNUDM QRVQ§FK G§UHN QHER S L ]GYLKQ§ D NOHVQ§ E LQ§ VWÕQ\ SULPUQ§P S HGPÕWHP MH YG\ WÕOHVQ· GRW\N SKRKDEED YH NWHU£P O]H UR]OLLW ÇW\ L HOHPHQW\SUYRWQÕY]QLNO£WÕOHVQRVWLEKWD7USDÙ7\WRÇW\ LHOHPHQW\GK½WXVHR]QDÇXM§ W£MDNR CYHONRKPRWQ£APDK½7EKWDDMVRX W§PQHMHOHPHQWUQÕM§PSURLWNRY·PUR]OLHQ§P]DNWHU£MLQHQ§ PRQR M§W GO S L MDN£NROLY DQDO·]H Y REODVWL WÕOHVQRVWL +ODYQ§ QHEROL SULPUQ§ S HGPÕW PHGLWDFH Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX VH QDO£] YG\ Y REODVWL WÕOHVQRVWL VHNXQGUQ§ S HGPÕW\ PHGLWDÇQ§ DQDO·]\ SRGO£KDM§UR]OLHQ§QDWÕOHVQ£DQHWÕOHVQ£<DWRMHSUYQ§SULQFLSUSD7DUSD7YLEK½JD 6HNXQGUQ§ S HGPÕW\ PHGLWDFH Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX MVRX ]D]QDPHQYQ\ GOH MHMLFK QOHHQ§ GR ÇW\ SRGNODG Y§PDYRVWL FDWW½UR7VDWLSDK½Q½ S LÇHP MVRX SRVWXSQÕ UR]SR]QYQ\ < SRNXG WR RGSRY§GLQNOLQDFLPHGLWXM§F§KR<GDO§DGDO§GUXK\WÕOHVQRVWLXYHGHQ£]GHYUSD7YLEK½JD 7\VHNXQGUQ§S HGPÕW\NWHU£MVRXS LSUYQ§PYLPQXW§UR]H]QQ\MDNRQHWÕOHVQ£MVRXSDNSRVWXSQÕ UR]SR]QYQ\ QHMSUYH GOH MHMLFK QOHLWRVWL GR RVWDWQ§FK SRGNODG VDWLSDK½QD D GOH GOH SDUDGLJPDW MHGQRWOLY·FKVDWLSDK½Q]QLFKMVRXY\EUQ\LPDWLFHREVDHQ£]GHYDUSD7YLEK½JD 2 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD 3RGOH YKRGQRVWL EÕKHP SRNURNX PHGLWDFH Y§PDYRVWL D YKOHGX MVRX YROHQ\ U]Q£ PDWLFH N ]D D]HQ§ MHY WÕOHVQ·FK D QHWÕOHVQ·FK -HGQRX ] QHMX§YDQÕM§FK MH UR]OLRYQ§ HVWL YQLW Q§FK D HVWL YQÕM§FK ]NODGHQ SUR§YQ§ VDå7½\DWDQD SÕWL WÕOHVQ·FK YL] p D MHGQ£ QHWÕOHVQ£ ,QVWUXNFH SUR SUDNWLFN· SRVWXS DQDO·]\ MVRX Y QHMVWUXÇQÕM§P D S HVWR ´SOQ£P SRGQ§ GRVWXSQ£ Y NQ§FH FWLKRGQ£KR 0DKVL 6D\DG 0HGLWDFH Y ©PDYRVWL D YKOHGX ]NODGQ© D SRNURÉLO¥ VWXSQ× 3UDKD NWHUREVDKXMHW£ WH[W%XGGKRY\9HON¥HÉLRSRGNODGHFKY ©PDYRVWL70DK½6DWLSDK½QD6XWWDY ÇHVN£PS HNODGX v FDNNKX GKÁW ÁGL SD±FDYLGKDåDMMKDWWLND U+SDåQÁPD_VHVDå EDKLUD U+SDåQÁPD__ (OHPHQWHP]UDN]DǧQDM§F§SÕWLFHWÕOHVQRVWLp;VHQD]·YYQLW Q§WÕOHVQRVW YHFKQD]E·YDM§F§VHQD]·YYQÕM§WÕOHVQRVW 5R]H]QYQ§YQLW Q§WÕOHVQRVWLQPWHG\GYWXREW§QRX´ORKXQDS S LSRKOD]HQ§VDPHWXQHYQ§PDW KHENRVWOWN\Q·EU]D]QDPHQYDWWROHFKWQ§YHSLÇNFKSUVWYL]p v YDRJDQGKRUDVRRMÁFDWWÁURPDKÁ EK+WÁWL_D##KDYLGKDåSL DYLQLEEKRJD U+SDå_VHVDåYLQLEEKRJD U+SDåQÁPD__ %DUYDpSDFKFKXLYQKPRWDÇW\ LYHONRKPRWQ£HOHPHQW\< WRMHRVP DVSHNW Y]MHPQÕQHRGGÕOLWHOQ£WÕOHVQRVWL]E·YDM§F§WÕOHVQRVWMHRGGÕOLWHOQ v FDNNKX GKÁW ÁGL SD±FDYLGKDåKDGD\D YDWWKXFDYDWWKX U+SDå QÁPD_LWDUDåDYDWWKXNDåQÁPD__ (OHPHQWHP]UDN]DǧQDM§F§SÕWLFHWÕOHVQRVWLDVWDQRYLWÕVUGFHp;pVH QD]·YDM§WÕOHVQVWDQRYLWÕ>QHEROLSURLWNRYRKQLVND@RVWDWQ§MHQHVWDQRYLWQ§ 3RMHP YDWWKX NWHU· P GOH NRQWH[WX L MLQ£ Y·]QDP\ ]GH R]QDÇXMH WDN]YDQRX VHQVLWLYQ§ SUR ÇLW§ SURSXVWQRXWÕOHVQRVWSDV½GD7USD=GHMVPHY REODVWLPHGLWDWLYQÕSURLWNRY£DQDO·]\DQHSUDFXMHPH DQLVHVNDOSHOHPDQLSRGPLNURVNRSHPNRPXMHWRWRMDVQ£QHSRNRX§VHLGHQWLILNRYDWVUGFHKDGD\D V RQ§PRUJQHPNWHU·SXPSXMHNUHYGRF£Y .QRQ7LND73DK½QDGHILQXMHKDGD\D7YDWWKX + \DåU SDåQLVVÁ\DPDQR GKÁWXFDPDQR YL±±Á D GKÁWXFDYDWWDQWL_WDå + U SDåPDQR GKÁWX\ÁFDPDQR YL±±Á D GKÁWX\ÁFDWDåVDåSD\XWWDNÁQDå 9 RQ£WÕOHVQRVWLVHG§FIXQJXM§HOHPHQWP\VODHOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOLWDWR WÕOHVQRVWSRGPLïXMHHOHPHQWP\VODHOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOLMDNR LV QLPL VSRMHQ£MHY\SRGSRUXM§F§SRGP§QNRXRVPRX] GYDFHWLÇW\ FDGKDPPÁQDåQLVVD\D SDFFD\HQDSDFFD\R__ 7DWRGHILQLFHMHRSDNRYDQÕXYGÕQDW£S LFKDUDNWHUL]RYQ§SRGP§QHN7LND73DK½QD 376IIDV RGSRY§GDM§F§PLDOWHUQDWLYDPLIRUPXORYQDSURRVWDWQ§VWDQRYLWÕSUR§YQ§ v Wë LQGUL\ÁQLFDNNK ÁGëQL SD±F HWL_D##KDYLGKDPSLLQGUL\D U+SDå QÁPD_LWDUDåDQLQGUL\DåQÁPD__ 7 L §G§F§VFKRSQRVWLpDHOHPHQWHP]UDN]DǧQDM§F§SÕWLFHS HGVWDYXM§RVPHUR §G§F§ WÕOHVQRVWLRVWDWQ§QHPDM§VFKRSQRVW §GLW 3 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v #KDSHWYÁÁSR GKÁWXåÁGLWRSD##KÁ\DGYÁGDVDYLGKDåRüÁULND U+SDå QÁPD_LWDUDåVXNKXPD U+SDåQÁPD__RüÁULND U+SDPHYDVDQWLNH U+SDåQÁPD_VXNKXPD U+SDåG+UHU+SDåQÁPD__ 9\M§PDMHHOHPHQWYRGDMHGYDQFWSUYQ§FKpp;QD]·YQRKUXE WÕOHVQRVWRVWDWQ§VHQD]·YMHPQWÕOHVQRVW+UXEWÕOHVQRVWMHEO§]N>NRQWDNWQ§@ WÕOHVQRVWMHPQWÕOHVQRVWMHY]GOHQWÕOHVQRVW v VDNDPPD MD U+SDåXSÁGLQQDå_VHVDåDQXSÁGLQQDåQÁPD__ 6NU]HÇLQ\SRYVWDOWÕOHVQRVWMHXFKRSHQ]E·YDM§F§MHQHXFKRSHQ v U+S Á\DWDQDPHY HNDåVDQLGDVVDQDå_LWDUDåDQLGDVVDQDå__ RüÁULNDåVDSSD#LJKDå_LWDUDåDSSD#LJKDå__ =NODGQD>HOHPHQWX@WYDUMHMHGLQYLGLWHOQRVWDWQ§QHMVRXYLGLWHOQ£ +UXEWÕOHVQRVWMHKPDWDWHOQÕKPRWQRVWDWQ§QHQ§KPDWDWHOQ >5+SDVVDMÁ\DQD 3RYVW¡Y¡QWÛOHVQRVWL @ v D##K LQGUL\ÁQLKDGD\D YDWWKXFDNDPPD MÁQ HYD__NÁ\D YL±±DWWL YDFë YL±±DWWLFDFLWWD MÁQ HYD__VDGGRXWX FLWWHKLMÁ\DWL__ODKXWÁ PXGXWÁNDPPD±±DWÁFDXWX FLWW ÁKÁUHKLMÁ\DQWL__MÁWL MDUÁ PDUDÁQLNLUDQDNHKLFLVDPX##KDKDQWL__XSDFD\DVDQWDWL\RMÁ\DQW ëWLYXFFDQWL__VHVÁQLQDYDU+SÁQLXWX FLWW ÁKÁUD NDPPHKLMÁ\DQWL__ 2VPHUR §G§F§WÕOHVQRVWLDVWDQRYLWÕVUGFHSRYVWYDM§]ÇLQ7ÕOHVQ·Y·UD]DVORYQ§ Y·UD]SRYVWYDM§] P\VOL=YXNSRYVWY] ´GRE§DP\VOL>7ÕOHVQ@SRK\EOLYRVW SRGGDMQRVWDPUWQRVWSRYVWYDM§] ´GRE§P\VOLDSRWUDY\=UR]HQ§VWUQXW§DXP§UQ§ QHSRYVWYDM§] QLÇHKR1UVWSRYVWY] WUYQ§MDNVH §N=E·YDM§F§FKGHYÕWGUXK WÕOHVQRVWLSRYVWY] ´GRE§P\VOLSRWUDY\D] ÇLQ 3 §SRQD C;M½A ]QDPHQ GRVORYD C]UR]HQA D R]QDÇXMH ]GH SRYVWQ§ QRY£ VLWXDFH QRY£ NRQILJXUDFH HOHPHQW 7DNH QDS CRVPHUR §G§F§ WÕOHVQRVWL D VWDQRYLWÕ VUGFH SRYVWYDM§A D WHSUYH Y NRQWH[WX ]PÕUQ£ VP\VORY£ D WÕOHVQ£ ÇLQQRVWL WHG\ ]H FKWÕQ·FK ÇLQ NDPPD MLP YODVWQ§ C §]HQ§A SRYVWY SUYÕ Y W£WR ÇLQQRVWL 3RMHP CXWXA MH ]GH S HORHQ MDNR C´GRE§A P DOH L GDO§ GHQRWDFH CSHULRGDA CNPLWQ§A CWHSORWDA CNOLPDA 3RMHP C½K½UDA R]QDÇXMH QHMHQ WÕOHVQRX SRWUDYX NDEDOLíN½UD7½KDUD 7 DOHLRVWDWQ§IRUP\MDNRQDS SRWUDYXVP\VOSKDVV ½K½UD >5+SD U+SDåÁGLND 3/YRGQWÛOHVQRVWDGDO! @ v ÁGLWRSD##KÁ\DVDWWDUDVDÁKÁURFÁ WL_D##KÁUDVD YLGKDPSLU+SD U+SDåQÁPD__ 3UYQ§FKVHGPQFW>MHY@DSRWUDYDS HGVWDYXM§RVPQFWGUXK WÕOHVQRVWL>YHYODVWQ§P VORYDVP\VOXWHG\@R]QDÇHQ£MDNRSYRGQ§ =GYRMHQ§PVORYDUSDMH]GHY\PH]HQDGHQRWDFHQD CWÕOHVQRVWYHYODVWQ§PVORYDVP\VOXAWHG\Y WRP QHMX§P SRMHW§ -DNR X YÕWLQ\ SOL SRMP MH L ]GH Y·]QDP SRGP§QÕQ NRQWH[WHP YL] Y\VYÕWOHQ§ Y XÇHEQLFL )U·ED 3OL 4 7 MD]\N WH[W\ NXOWXUD %UQR VWU QLNROLY VORYR Q·EU NRQWH[WXOQÕ + + 5 SD $U SD 9LEKÁJD CUSDA XFHOHQ· Y·URN MH ]NODGQ§ MHGQRWNRX Y·]QDPX 1HMYHREHFQÕML R]QDÇXMH SRMHP WÕOHVQRVW Y SURWLNODGX NH YHPX QHWÕOHVQ£PX MH MH YHREHFQÕ ]DKUQRYQR SRG SRMPHP 9 X§P VORYD VP\VOX R]QDÇXMH SRMHP CUSDA YHNHURX CQ½PDA S HGPÕW YLGÕQ§ WHG\ WYDU D EDUYX p QHEROL U SD7 ½\DWDQD ] Q§ QHQ§ Y\ORXÇHQD EDUYD YDïïD 7DNWR SRMDW YLGLWHOQ WÕOHVQRVW PH P§W NRPSOH[Q§ NRQILJXUDFLVDïK½QDS HVWRYDNREVDHQRXY MHGQROLW£PRSWLFN£PHOHPHQWXUSD7GK½WXNWHU·MH R]QDÇHQ MDNR QLPLWWD REUD] ÇL S HGVWDYD -LQ· NRQWH[WXOQÕ GHILQRYDQ· Y·]QDP SRMPX CUSDA VH MDNRXNROLYRSWLFN\]D]QDPHQDWHOQRXVWUXNWXUXIXQJXM§F§Y SURFHVXYLGÕQ§MDNRYQÕM§]NODGQD Y]WDKXMH QD VWUXNWXU\ RSURWÕQ£ RG PRWLYDÇQ§FK HPRÇQ§FK D NRJQLWLYQÕ LGLRV\QNUDWLFN·FK DVSHNW WHG\ QD WDN §NDM§F VWDQRYLWÕ CÇLVW£ IRUP\A QHER CWYDU\A YLGÕQ§ D VO\HQ§ NWHU£ QHPDM§ GQ£ YQÕM§ WÕOHVQ£ YDWWKX YH VYÕWÕ NDGRGHQQ§ VP\VOQRVWL N½PD7ORND 3UR WDNWR SRMDWRX WÕOHVQRVW MH Y ÇHVN£P S HNODGX SRX§YQ Y·UD] CWYDUA SRKURXHQ§ < QDS Y R]QDÇHQ§ REODVW§ SUR§YQ§ EÕKHP PHGLWDÇQ§KR MK½QD MDNR CVYÕW WYDUA USD7ORND S §SDGQÕ MDNR CWYDUXSURVW· VYÕWA D7USD7ORND N ÇHPX MHSRGQRY\VYÕWOHQ§Yp v NÁ\D YL±±DWWL ÁGLNDåSD±FD YLGKDåSLU+SD YLNÁURQÁPD__ ÁNÁVD GKÁWXNLUDU+SD SDULFFKHGRQÁPD__ MÁWL MDUÁ PDUDQÁLWëLODNNKDD U+SÁQLQÁPD__ 7ÕOHVQ·PY·UD]HP]DǧQDM§F§SÕWLFHVHQD]·YWÕOHVQ]PÕQD (OHPHQWSURVWRUMHSRM§PQMDNRY\PH]HQ§WÕOHVQRVW§ =URGVWUQXW§DXP§UQ§MVRXW LFKDUDNWHULVWLN\WÕOHVQRVWL >.ÁPDORNHU+SDå 7ÛOHVQRVWVYÛWDVP\VOQRVWL @ v VDEEÁQLSDQ HWÁQLU+SÁQLNÁPD ORNHDQ+QÁQLODEEKDQWL VDåVHGDMÁQD±F HYDRSDSÁWLNÁQD±FD__ 9HFKQ\W\WR>GUXK\@WÕOHVQRVWLMVRXYHVYÕWÕVP\VOQRVWL]FHODGRVWXSQ£MDNR LW\ Y]QLNO£] SOD]P\DY]QLNO£EH]] HMP£S §ÇLQ\ 3V\FKRNRVPRORJLH REVDHQ Y DEKLGKDPPÕ UR]OLXMH W L VYÕW\ VYÕW VP\VOQRVWL ]KUXED RGSRY§G VYÕWX QD§ NDGRGHQQ§ ]NXHQRVWL Y QÕP MVRX ]DKUQXW\ L N½PD7ORND MHQ LYRWQ§ REODVWL QL§FK GHY½ G£PRQ \DNNK½ D SHNHOQ·FK E\WRVW§ QLUD\LN½ VYÕW WYDU USD7ORND Y QÕP EUDKP½ PH]L NWHU·PL QHGRFK]§ N GHIRUPDFL Y]WDK ]SVREHQ·PL QHQYLVW§ DQHER FKWLYRVW§ WYDUXSURVW·VYÕWDUSD7ORNDYHNWHU£PQHO]HLGHQWLILNRYDWGQ£E\WRVWL ERVWHY V§GO§ Y\§ ER]L v DÑDMD MDOÁEXMÁQDåSDQDLWWKL SXULVÁQDåSD#LVDQGKLNÁOHNÁ\D GDVDND EKÁYD GDVDND YDWWKX GDVDND YDVHQDWëLGDVDNÁQL SÁWXEKDYDQWL__QDSXåVDNDVVDSDQDEKÁYD GDVDNDQDWWKL_WDWKÁ SD#KDPD NDSSLNÁQDå_WHVDåSDQDSDYDWWLNÁOHNDPHQDFDNNKX GDVDND VRWDGDVDND JKÁDGDVDND MLYKÁGDVDNÁQLSÁWXEKDYDQWL__ $YDNHQVN£DPXVN£>E\WRVWL@]UR]HQ£] YDM§ÇNDQHER] GÕORK\]§VNYDM§S LQDSRMHQ§ W LGHV§WN\MHYMPHQRYLWÕGHV§WNXWÕODGHV§WNXSRKODY§DGHV§WNX>WÕOHVQ£KR@VWDQRYLWÕ %H]SRKODYQ§YDNQHPDM§GHV§WNXSRKODY§VWHMQÕWDNE\WRVWLY SUYQ§PVWGLX>Y·YRMH@ 7\WRE\WRVWL]§VNDM§EÕKHPY·YRMHURYQÕ GHV§WNX]UDNXGHV§WNXVOXFKXGHV§WNXÇLFKXD GHV§WNXFKXRY£KRRUJQX 5 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v WHVXDYLQLEEKRJD U+SÁQD±F HYDNÁ\ LQGUL\D MëYLW LQGUL\ÁQD±FD YDVHQDNÁ\D GDVDNDåYHGLWDEEDå__HYDåVHVD GDVDNÁQLSL \RMHWYÁYHGLWDEEÁQL__ 9]MHPQÕQHRGGÕOLWHOQWÕOHVQRVWpVSROXVHVFKRSQRVW§RUJQXKPDWXpD §G§F§VFKRSQRVW§LYRWQRVWLpVHSRM§PMDNRGHV§WNDWÕOD2EGREQÕVHFKSH VSRMHQ§Y RVWDWQ§FKGHV§WNFK >5+SDORNHU+SDå 7ÛOHVQRVWWYDUXSURVW©KRVYÛWD @ v U+SD ORNHSDQDJKÁD MLYKÁ JKDQGKD UDVD SKR##DEEÁQLF HYD LWWK LQGUL\D SXULV LQGUL\ÁQLFDQDODEEKDQWL__ DVD±±LQDåSDQDFDNNKX VRWD YDWWKX VDGGÁQLSLQDODEEKDQWL__ 9 WYDUXSURVW£PVYÕWÕYDNQHQ§>WÕOHVQRVW@ÇLFKXMD]\NDSDFKXFKXWLp DQLKPDWDWHOQp; URYQÕ GQ£ §]HQ§HQVNRVW§QHERPXQRVW§p 8 E\WRVW§EH]YQ§PQ§QHMVRXDQLVWDQRYLWÕ]UDNXDVOXFKXDQL]YXN v DU+SD ORNHSDQDU+SDPHYDQDWWKL__QDDU+SDND VDWWÁQDå SD#LVDQGKLNÁOHQDVDGGRYL\Á_ 9WYDUXSURVW£PVYÕWÕWHG\QHQ§GQWÕOHVQRVW7YDUXSURVW£E\WRVWLQHMVRXDQLMDNR ]YXNY ÇDVHY]DQ£ WLU+SD YLEKÁJRQL##KLWR__ W§PMHDQDO·]DWÕOHVQRVWLGRNRQÇHQD 6 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD >$5* 3$9,%+À*$ $QDO½]DQHWÛOHVQ©KR @ v DU+SDåSDQDFLWWD FHWDVLND QLEEÁD YDVHQDWL YLGKDå__ 1HWÕOHVQ£MHYDNWURM§GOHUR]GÕOHQ§QDP\VOVORN\P\VOLDQLEEQX DUSDA RGND]XMH ÇVWLFH CSDQDA ]QDPHQDM§F§ CRSURWL WRPXA QHER CYDNA QD HGFKR]§WH[WUR]HE§UDM§F§WÕOHVQRVWCUSDASURWRDE\E\O\Y\ORXÇHQ\MLQ£Y·]QDP\QH CQHWÕOHVQ£A 3 L GHILQRYQ§ SRMPX C S 0\VO MH R]QDÇRYQD W HPL V\QRQ\P\ X§YDQ·PL SRGOH NRQWH[WX 3RMPHP CFLWWDA VH R]QDÇXMH P\VO S HGHY§P S L DQDO·]H U]Q·FK VWDY P\VOL D MHMLFK HWLFN·FK SRWHQFLDOLW EODKRGUQ£KR NXVDOD ]KRXEQ£KR DNXVDOD D QHXWUOQÕ Y·VOHGQ£KR YLS½ND QHER IXQNÇQ§KR NUL\D 2SHUDFLRQDOL]RYQ\ MVRX W\WR NDWHJRULH WHFKQLNDPL VOHGRYQ§ P\VOL FLWW½QXSDVVDQ½ MH X§Y W HW§ VDWLSDK½QD 3RMHP CPDQRAR]QDÇXMHDNWXOQÕDNWLYQ§MHGQRWXP\VOLYHVWUXNWXUOQ§DSURFHVXOQ§DQDO·]HQHEROLWHQSUYÕ SRYVWDO· CRUJQ P\VOA PDQR7GK½WX QHER IXQJXMH MDNRWR SV\FKLFN· DSDUW 3RMHP CRUJQ YÕGRP§ P\VOLA PDQR7YL½ïD7GK½WX NWHU· CYL½ïDA R]QDÇXMH P\VO YH IXQNFL SR]QYDM§F§ MHGQRWN\ YÕGRP§ Y]WDHQ£KR QD DNWXOQ§ S HGPÕW ½ODPEDïD P\VOL 3RGUREQ£ Y\VYÕWOHQ§ SRGY )U·ED 3V\FKRORJLH]YOGQ©LYRWD7$SOLNDFHPHWRG\DEKLGKDPPD%UQRNDSLWROD -HY\ NWHU£ O]H UR]OLLW MDNR NRPSRQHQW\ P\VOL MVRX R]QDÇRYQ\ SRMPHP CFHWDVLN½A S HNOGDQ·P MDNRCVORN\P\VOLA.URPÕSDGHVWLVORHNP\VOLNWHU£GHWHUPLQXM§VWUXNWXUXMHM§IRUPDFHVDíNK½UD SDW § W£ F§WÕQ§ YHGDQ½ D YQ§PQ§ VD½ GR NDWHJRULH FHONHP SDGHVWL GYRX MHY P\VOL FHWDVLN½7 GKDPP½2SHUDFLRQOQÕMVRXVORN\P\VOLGHWHUPLQRYQ\PDWLFHPLDSRVWXS\MHGQDNVOHGRYQ§MHY GKDPP½QXSDVVDQ½ MHGQDN SU]NXPX MHY GKDPPDYLFD\D NWHU£ MVRX X§YQ\ Y UPFL ÇWYUW£ VDWLSDK½Q\3 HKOHGMHGQRWOLY·FKVORHNY W\SHFKP\VOLGYWDEXONDY GRGDWNX 3RMHP CQLEE»íDA QHQ§ PRQR RSHUDFLRQOQÕ GHILQRYDW MLQDN QH XVNXWHÇQÕQ§P YHFK G§OǧFK SRVWXS %XGGKRY\QDXN\DGRVDHQ§PMHM§KRF§OHQHS HNOGPHKR-DNRYEHFSUYQ§QHM]NODGQÕM§GHILQLFH MH %XGGKRX IRUPXORYQD PDWLFH CÇW\ XOHFKWLO·FK SUDYGA FDWW½UL7DUL\D7VDFF½QL ÇHVN\ WXWR PDWLFL Y MHM§FKYHFKLPSOLNDF§FKY\VYÕWOXM§1\»QDWLORND 6ORYR%XGGKRYR3UDKDD)U·ED3OL7MD]\N WH[W\NXOWXUD%UQR >&LWWDYLEKÁJD $QDO½]DP\VOL @ v WDWWKDFLWWDåWÁYDVDNKHSHQD_ SD#LVDQGKL EKDYDJ ÁYDMMDQD GDVVDQ ÁGL VDPSD#LFFKDQD VDQWëUDD YRWWKDSDQD MDYDQD WDG ÁODPEDD FXWL YDVHQD_GDVDGKÁ#KLWDå__ 9 WRPWR>NRQWH[WXMHVWUXÇQÕSRM§PQD@P\VOY VRXYLVORVWHFKGHVHWLVWGL§ QDSRMHQ§ NRQWLQXLWD ]SR]RURYQ§ YLGÕQ§DWG S LM§PQ§ ]NRXPQ§ ]MLWÕQ§ RYOLYQÕQ§ XUÇRYQ§ ]PL]HQ§ KLWDÙ Y]QLNDM§ Y SURFHVX P\VOL FLWWD7YßWKL Y QÕP MH MHMLFK SR DG§ GHWHUPLQRYQR VDPDQDQWDUD7SDFFD\D D SRGP§QNRX VSXWÕQ§ XSDQLVD\D7 7DWR VWGLD SRGP§QNRX EH]SURVW HGQ§ QYD]QRVWL SDFFD\D $E\FKRP E\OL VFKRSQL Y PHGLWDFL Y§PDYRVWL UR]H]QDW WHQWR VOHG SRW HEXMHPH ]QW WÕFK RVPGHVWGHYÕWVWDYYÕGRP§NWHU£SURYGÕM§MHGQRWOLY£IXQNFHYÕGRP§YL½ïD7NLFFDY XYHGHQ·FK GHVHWL VWGL§FK SURFHVX P\VOL 3DUDGLJPDWD SUR PHGLWDÇQ§ XFKRSHQ§ VWUXNWXUOQ§FK D SURFHVXOQ§FK VRXYLVORVW§WÕFKWRIXQNF§UHVSHNWLYHNRJQLWLYQ§FKVWGL§MVRXSRGQDY SRVOHGQ§FKRGVWDYF§FKNDSLWRO\ &LWWDYLEK½JD SRǧQDMH p 'DO§ SRGUREQRVWL N WÕPWR VWGL§P MVRX XYHGHQ\ YH YHON£P SURVODYHQ£P G§OH $EKLGKDPPD7$YDW½UD NWHU£ QP FWLKRGQ· %XGGKDGDWWD DXWRU WH[WX 5SD7$USD79LEK½JD ]DQHFKDO MDNR VNYÕO· NRPHQW N W£WR SUDNWLFN£ S §UXÇFH 2EÕ XYHGHQ£ %XGGKDGDWWRY\ NQLK\ MVRX 7 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD YEHF SUYQ§PL WH[W\ YH NWHU·FK MH GHVDWHUR IXQNÇQ§FK VWGL§ SURFHVX P\VOL V\VWHPDWLFN\ Y\VYÕWOHQR ]SVREHPSUDNWLFN\SRXLWHOQ·PY PHGLWDFL9 $EKLGKDPPD7$YDW½UDFLWWD7QLGGHVR;MHXYHGHQD V\QRSVHNWHUGYILORVRILFN\LQVSLUXM§F§S HVWRYDNQDSUD[LY]WDHQRXGHILQLFLP\VOL + FLWWDåFHWDVLNDåU SDåQLEEÁQDQ WL 0\VOVORN\P\VOLWÕOHVQRVWQLEEQD MVRXXN]Q\MDNRWRÇW\ LQHM]D]§VNXWHÇQRVWLS LY\VYÕWOHQ§ÇW\ SUDYG QLUXWWDURFDWXGKÁGHVD\ëGKDPPHFDWXVDFFDSSDNÁVDQR__ WDWWKDFLWWDQ WLYLVD\DYLMMÁQDQDåFLWWDå__WDVVDSDQDNRYDFDQDWWKR__ YXFFDWH_VDEEDVD JÁKDND YDVHQDSDQDFLQWHWë WLSLFLWWDåDWWDQRVDQWÁQDå 0\VOWX]QDPHQXYÕGRPRYQ§VLREODVWLVYÕWD&RDOH]QDPHQWHQWRY·URN" =QDPHQWRHSUYÕW§PMDNYHGYGRVRXYLVORVW§P\VO§P\VOS LÇHP YDNLVYRMLYODVWQ§NRQWLQXLWXP\VO§P\VO YÁFLQRWë WLSLFLWWDå__ ## 5R]OLRYQ§SURYG§P\VOSURVW HGQLFWY§PVY£ YODVWQ§SURPÕQOLYRVWLGRSRMP GYXYÕGRPÕQ£UR]OLHQ§]REUD]XMHY\E§UFRPE·WSRFKRSHQRFRMH Y XYÕGRPÕQ£PWR>SUH]HQWXMH@XYÕGRPXM§F§PXVL YLFLWWDNDUD ÁFLWWDåDWWDQRFLWWDWÁ\DYÁSD±±DWWL\DPSLYL±±Á H_YLFLWWH FLWWDNDPPDNHFLWWDVDPPXWLGD KDEEÁYL±±Á HLGKDYL±±XQÁ__ v YLWWKÁUHQDSDQDHN+QDQDYXWL YLGKDåKRWL__NDWKDå__ 9 SRGUREQ£PUR]OLHQ§MH>VWDY P\VOL@RVPGHVWGHYÕW-DN" 5R]ERU YLWWK½UD ]GH ]QDPHQ Y§F QH UR]YHGHQ§ S HGFKR]§KR VRXKUQX VDíNKHSD SURYHGHQ£KR ] KOHGLVNDSURFHVX3URWRHVHMHGQRDQDO·]XWÕOHVQ£KRDQHWÕOHVQ£KRNWHUMHSURYGÕQDY PHGLWDFL D ]D ´ÇHOHP SRNURNX Y PHGLWDFL MH UR]ERU Y]WDHQ QD GRYHGQRVWL D MHMLFK Y·VOHGN\ (WLFN\ GRYHGQ£ NXVDOD MH EODKRGUQ£ GREU£ D YHGH NH DVWQ£PX Y·VOHGQ£PX SUR§YQ§ 1HDVWQ£ ]O£ EROHVWQÕ SUR§YDQ£ÇLQ\DMHMLFKGVOHGN\MVRXY·VOHGNHPHWLFN\QHGRYHGQ·FKDNXVDODVWDYP\VOL'DO§PL ] HWLN\ Y\SO·YDM§F§PL DVSHNW\ MH MHGQDN S §MHPQ D QHS §MHPQ GLPHQ]H SUR§YQ§ YHGDQ½ MHGQDN DOWHUQDWLY\ PRXGU£KR DQHER ]DVOHSHQ£KR SRM§PQ§ ½ïD GLKL 6WDY\ P\VOL PRKRX E·W FKWÕQ£ ÇLOL YQÕM§PLIRUPDFHPLRYOLYïRYQ\VDVDíNK½ULNDPRKRXE·WW£HWLFN\QHXWUOQ§PLY·VOHGN\YLS½ND DQHERÇLVWÕIXQNÇQ§PLSURFHV\NUL\D7RPXRGSRY§GQVOHGXM§F§ÇOHQÕQ§ >.XVDODFLWWÁQL %ODKRG¡UQ©W\S\P\VOL @ >.ÁPÁYDFDUDFLWWÁQL 7\S\P\VOLYREODVWLVP\VOQRVWL @ v 8 VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDåHNDu WLLPÁQLD##KDNÁPÁYDFDUD NXVDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S>P\VOL@ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§FKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§FKWÕQ·W\S < WÕFKWRRVPVHQD]·YEODKRGUQ£W\S\P\VOLY REODVWLVP\VOQRVWL v WHKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_PDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁW ÁYDMMÁQ DQWDUDåU+SDåYÁVDGGDåYÁJDQGKDåYÁUDVDåYÁ SKR##KDEEDåYÁGKDPPDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_GÁQD VëOD EKÁYDQ ÁGëVXD±±DWDUD PD\ÁQLKXWYÁXSSDMMDQWL__ 9]QLNDM§VHG§FYVUGFL>MDNRWRVWDQRYLWL@DQHEREH]VWDQRYLWÕEH]SURVW HGQÕSR ]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPYÕGRP§P\VOLFKSDM§FEXÉWYDUQHER]YXNQHERSDFKQHER FKX QHERGRW\NQHERMHYP\VOLMDNRS HGPÕWY\WY HQ\>YÕGRP§PG §YHGÕODQ£KR@ GYQ§HWLFN£KRMHGQQ§PHGLWDFHDSRGREQ·FK>ÇLQ@ NXVDODMHGQQ§QHERPOXYHQ§DY]SRP§QQ§ YLS½ND NWHU£ MHGQDN SVRE§ DVWQ£ SUR§YQ§ Y NDGRGHQQ§P LYRWÕ 7\WREODKRGUQ£VWDY\P\VOLGRSURY]HM§HWLFN\GRYHGQ£ QD QÕM 3URWR PDM§ Y·VOHGN\ MHGQDN VORX§ MDNR S HGPÕW\ P\VOL NWHU MH Y·FKRGLVNHP SUR NXOWLYRYQ§ PHGLWDÇQ§FK GRYHGQRVW§ MK½QDSRSVDQ·FKY QVOHGXM§F§PWH[WX RE]YOWÕSURGRVDKRYQ§VWDYSRKURXHQ§ >-KÁQDFLWWÁQL 7\S\P\VOLYSRKURX>HQ @ v YLWDNND YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå SD#KDPDMMKÁQD NXVDOD FLWWDå YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå GXWL\DMMKÁQD NXVDOD FLWWDu SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåWDWL\DMMKÁQD NXVDOD FLWWDu VXNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåFDWXWWKDMMKÁQD NXVDOD FLWWDu XSHNNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåSD±FDPDMMKÁQD NXVDOD FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLSD±FDU+SÁYDFDUD NXVDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 3RM§PQ§PUR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ EODKRGUQP\VOSUYQ§KRSRKURXHQ§ UR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ EODKRGUQP\VOGUXK£KRSRKURXHQ§ QDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ EODKRGUQP\VOW HW§KRSRKURXHQ§ WÕVW§PDMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQEODKRGUQP\VOÇWYUW£KRSRKURXHQ§ Y\URYQDQRVW§DMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ EODKRGUQP\VOSW£KRSRKURXHQ§ < WÕFKWRSÕW QD]·YPHEODKRGUQ£W\S\P\VOLREODVWLWYDU 9 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v HNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\ HYD_\DWKÁUDKDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWD NXVDO ÁQDQWDUDå_EKÁYDQÁ PD\ÁQ HYDKXWYÁ_SD#KDYë NDVL ÁGëNDåÁODPELWYÁXSSDMDQWL__SD±FDPDåSDQDFKDü ÁUDPPDDå KRWL__ v 9]QLNDM§MHGLQÕYH>VWDQRYLWL@ VUGFHVHG§FQVOHGXM§FRGSRY§GDM§F§PXEODKRGUQ£PX >VWDYXP\VOL@VSRMHQ£PXV YÕGÕQ§PNWHU·PNDVLíX]HPÕ DQHERQÕMDN·GDO§>WDNRY· PHGLWDÇQ§S §SUDYHN@MDNRS HGPÕWY SW£P>SRKURXHQ§@MHYDNHVWS HGPÕW ÁNÁV DQD±F Á\DWDQD VDPÁSDWWL NXVDOD FLWWDå YL±±Á D±F Á\DWDQD VDPÁSDWWL NXVDOD FLWWDå ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD VDPÁSDWWL NXVDOD FLWWDå QHYD VD±±Á Q ÁVD±± Á\DWDQD VDPÁSDWWL NXVDOD FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLFDWWÁULDU+SÁYDFDUD NXVDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ %ODKRGUQP\VOGRVDHQ§ REODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLSURVWRUX EODKRGUQP\VOGRVDHQ§ REODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLYÕGRP§ EODKRGUQP\VOGRVDHQ§ REODVWLQLFRW\ EODKRGUQP\VOGRVDHQ§ REODVWLDQL;YQ§PQ§;DQL;QHYQ§PQ§ < WRWRMVRXÇW\ LGUXK\EODKRGUQ£P\VOLYHWYDUXSURVW£REODVWL v KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD ±ÁD VDPSD\XWWD NXVDO ÁQDQWDUDåEKÁYDQÁ PD\DQ HYDKXWYÁ_ \DWKÁQXU+SDå NDVL XJJKÁ#LP ÁNÁVD±FD SD#KDP ÁUXSSD YL±±ÁD±FD QDWWKL EKÁYD±FD ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD±FDÁODPELWYÁ XSSDMMDQWL__ 9]QLNDM§Y VUGFLVHG§FQHERQHVHG§FRGSRY§GDM§FS HGFK]HM§F§EODKRGUQ£>P\VOL@ GRSURY]HQ£Y\URYQDQRVW§VSRMHQ£V YÕGÕQ§PMDNRS HGPÕWPDM§F§EXÉ SURVWRU Y]QLNO·RGVWUDQÕQ§PNDVLí\DQHER YÕGRP§SUYQ§KRQHWÕOHVQ£KR>SRKURXHQ§@DQHER QHS §WRPQRVW>S HGPÕWX@DQHER QLFRWXFRE\]NODGQX 3 L GRVDHQ§ WYDUXSURVW·FK SRKURXHQ§ DUS½YDFDUDMMK½QD QHEROL ½UXSSD GRFK]§ N REUDFHQ§ P\VOL Y SW£PSRKURXHQ§REODVWLWYDUXUS½YDFDUDMMK½QD3 HNRQYQ§PVHEXÉNRQWH[WS HGPÕWXDQHER YQLW Q§]NODGQDP\VOLDMMKDWLND½\DW½QDVWYS HGPÕWHPPHGLWDFHMDN]Q]RUïXMHWDEXOND 7\SP\VOLWYDUXSURVW£REODVWL PXV§S HNRQDW PXV§MDNRS HGPÕWXFKRSLW ½UXSSD7FLWWD DWLNNDPLWDEED ½ODPELWDEED REODVWQHNRQHÇQRVWLSURVWRUX WYDUNDVLQ\ SURVWRU NDVLïD7USD ½N½VD REODVWQHNRQHÇQRVWLYÕGRP§ SURVWRU YÕGRP§SUYQ§»UXSSD YL½ï 7DF 7½\DWDQD ½N½VD SDKDPD7½UXSSD7YL½ïD REODVWQLFRW\ YÕGRP§SUYQ§»UXSSD QHS §WRPQRVWS HGPÕWX QDWWKL7EK½YD SDKDPD7YL½ïD QDWWKL7EK½YD DQL;YQ§PQ§;DQL;QHYQ§PQ§ QHS §WRPQRVWS HGPÕWX YÕGRP§W HW§»UXSSD QHYD7VD½7Q 7½VD 7½\DWDQD QDWWKL7EK½YD WDWL\D7½UXSSD7YL½ïD ½N½V 7DQDF 7½\DWDQD 10 + + 5 SD $U SD 9LEKÁJD >/RNXWWDUDFLWWÁQL 1DGVYÛWVN©W\S\P\VOL @ v GL##KL YLFLNLFFKÁ VDPXJJKÁWLNDuVRWÁSDWWL PDJJD FLWWDå NÁPDUÁJD Y\ÁSÁGÁQDåWDQXNDUDåVDNDGDJÁPL PDJJD FLWWDå NÁPDUÁJD Y\ÁSÁGÁQDåVDPXJJKÁWLNDåDQÁJÁPL PDJJD FLWWDå U+SDUÁJD DU+SDUÁJD PÁQD XGGKDFF ÁYLMM ÁGL SD±F XGGKDP EKÁJL\D VDå\RMDQD VDPXJJKÁWLNDåDUDKDWWD PDJJD FLWWD±FÁ WLLPÁQLFDWWÁULORNXWWDUD NXVDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 0\VOVWH]N\YVWXSXGRSURXGXNWHURGVWUDïXMH>]YUFHQ£@Q]RU\DSRFK\ERYDÇQRVW P\VOVWH]N\MHGQRXVHQDYUDFHM§F§KRNWHURVODEXMHVP\VOQRXWRXKXD]ORYOL P\VOVWH]N\QHQYUDWXNWHURGVWUDïXMHVP\VOQRXWRXKXD]ORYOL P\VOVWH]N\RSURWÕQ§NWHURGVWUDïXMHWRXKXSRVYÕWHFKWYDU DWYDUXSURVW·FK GRP·OLYRVWYQLW Q§QHNOLGMDNR LYHFKSÕW]DVOHSHQRVW§SRǧQDM§F§FKY\§FKSRXW < WRWRMVRXÇW\ LEODKRGUQ£QDGVYÕWVN£W\S\P\VOL v LPHVXFDWXVXORNXWWDUD NXVDOD FLWWHVXSD#KDPDåKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\ HYD_LWDUÁQLWëLQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ\DWKÁUDKDå_±ÁD VDPSD\XWWD NXVDO ÁQDQWDUDåEKÁYDQÁ PD\ÁQ HYDKXWYÁ DYLVHVHQDFDWWÁULSLQLEEÁQDåÁODPELWYÁ_ VX±±DWRYLPRNNKR DQLPLWWRYLPRNNKR DSSDLKLWRYLPRNNKR WLQÁPHQDXSSDMMDQWë__ WLLPÁQLFDWWÁULORNXWWDUD NXVDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ $ % & = WÕFKWRÇW\ QDGVYÕWVN·FKW\S P\VOLMHQRPWHQSUYQ§VHG§Y VUGFLRVWDWQ§W LY VUGFL VHG§FDQHERY VUGFLQHVHG§FQVOHGXM§MLPRGSRY§GDM§F§EODKRGUQ£V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ£ P\VOLY\WYR HQ£PHGLWDF§YHFKQ\ÇW\ LQLEEQXMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FY]QLNDM§MDNR RVYRER]HQ§SU]GQRWRX RVYRER]HQ§EH]H]QDN RVYRER]HQ§QHONDYRVW§ < 7RMVRXÇW\ LEODKRGUQ£QDGVYÕWVN£W\S\P\VOL $ % & HWWÁYDWÁHNDYëVDWLNXVDODFLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 7RMHWHG\GYDFHWMHGQDEODKRGUQ·FKW\S P\VOL >$NXVDODFLWWÁQL 1HEODKRG¡UQ©W\S\P\VOL @ v VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåGL##KLJDWD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå WLLPÁQLD##KDOREKD VDKDJDWD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 11 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·VH]DXMDWRVW§VSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S>P\VOL@ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·VH]DXMDWRVW§VSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]]DXMDWRVWLVSRQWQQ§W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]]DXMDWRVWLFKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·VH]DXMDWRVW§VSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·VH]DXMDWRVW§VSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]]DXMDWRVWLVSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]]DXMDWRVWLFKWÕQ·W\S < WRWRMHRVPFKWLYRVW§GRSURY]HQ·FKW\S P\VOL v GRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåSD#LJKD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå GRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåSD#LJKD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå WLLPÁQLGYHSD#LJKD VDPSD\XWWDå FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ v VPXWNHPGRSURY]HQ·V QHQYLVW§VSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S VPXWNHPGRSURY]HQ·V QHQYLVW§VSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S < WRWRMVRXGYDV QHQYLVW§VSRMHQ£W\S\P\VOL XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå YLFLNLFFKÁ VDPSD\XWWDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåXGGKDFFD VDPSD\XWWD± F HWLLPÁQLGYHPRP+KD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V SRFK\ERYDÇQRVW§VSRMHQ· Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V QHNOLGHPVSRMHQ· < WRWRMVRXGYD]DVOHSHQ£W\S\P\VOL v LPHVXSDQDGYÁGDVDDNXVDOD FLWHVXGYHSD#LJKD FLWWÁQLHNDQWHQD KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_LWDUÁQLQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_DYLVHVHQD FKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁPDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDåXSSDMMDQWL__ 0H]LWÕPLWRGYDQFWLQHEODKRGUQ·PLW\S\P\VOLY]QLNDM§W\GYDVSRMHQ£V QHQYLVW§ MHGLQÕVHG§FY VUGFLW\RVWDWQ§Y VUGFLVHG§FQHERQHVHG§FYHFKQ\SRM§PDM§MHGHQ]H HVWLS HGPÕW SRGOHWRKRSRNWHU£P]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPYÕGRP§P\VOLY]QLNDM§ QL##KLWÁQLGYÁGDVDDNXVDOD FLWWÁQL__ 'RNRQÇHQRMHGYDQFWQHEODKRGUQ·FKW\S P\VOL 9 HFKQ\GRVXGXYHGHQ£W\S\P\VOLMDNQHEODKRGUQ£WDNEODKRGUQ£MDNRLPH]LEODKRGUQ·PLW\S\ RQ\QOHHM§F§GRPHGLWDÇQ§FKREODVW§GRVDKRYQ§SRKURXHQ§QHERQDGVYÕWVN£VWH]N\<YHFKQ\PDM§ FKDUDNWHUDNWLYQ§ 9 QVOHGXM§F§PWH[WXXYHGHQ£W\S\P\VOLMVRXY·VOHGQ·PLVWDY\DY WRPWRVP\VOXSDVLYQ§DÇNROLYVH SRG§OHM§QDSURYGÕQ§U]Q·FKDNWLYLWP\VOL 12 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD >9LSÁNDFLWWÁQL 9½VOHGQ©VWDY\P\VOL @ >.ÁPÁYDFDUDNXVDOD YLSÁND FLWWÁQL 9½VOHGQ©EODK©VWDY\YREODVWLVP\VO/ @ v FDNNK Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DL##KD VDPPDWDåU+S Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_ÁORN +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå FDNNKX YL±±ÁDå__ VRW Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DL##KD VDPPDWDåVDGG Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_ÁNÁV +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå VRWD YL±±ÁDå__ JKÁ Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DL##KD VDPPDWDåJDQGK Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_YÁ\R GKÁW +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁ PDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåJKÁD YL±±ÁDå__ MLYK Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DL##KD VDPPDWDåUDV Á\DWDQDåÁODPELWYÁ XGDN +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYD XSSDMMDWLNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåMLYKÁ YL±±ÁDå__ NÁ\ Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DL##KD VDPPDWDåSKR##KDEE Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_SD#KDY +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLNXVDOD YLSÁNDåVXNKD VDKDJDWDåNÁ\D YL±±ÁDå__ 1D]NODGQÕ]UDNXVHG§FS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXWYDUMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F VYÕWORMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOL WDNY]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§]UDNX 1D]NODGQÕVOXFKXVHG§FS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQX]YXNMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F SURVWRUMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOL WDNY]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§VOXFKX 1D]NODGQÕÇLFKXVHG§FS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXSDFKMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F Y]GXFKMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOL WDNY]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§ÇLFKX 1D]NODGQÕMD]\NXVHG§FS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXFKX MDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F YRGXMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDN Y]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§FKXWL 1D]NODGQÕWÕODVHG§FS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXGRW\NMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F ]HPLMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDN Y]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@S §MHPQ·PF§WÕQ§PGRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§WÕOD 13 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_SD±FDQQDåNXVDOD YLSÁND YL±±ÁDP D±±DWDU ÁQDQWDUDå _WDVV HY ÁUDPPDDåJDKHWYÁXSSDMMDWL NXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå VDPSD#LFFKDQD FLWWDå__ 9 VUGFLVHG§FEODK·PY·VOHGQ·PW\SPYÕGRP§SÕWL>VP\VO@QVOHGXM§FSUYÕMHMLFK S HGPÕWEHURXFY]QLNMDNRWREODK·Y·VOHGQ·Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQW P\VOL>QD]·YDQ·@P\VOS LM§PQ§ v KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_L##KD VDPPDWHVXFKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁ WDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_ NXVDOD YLSÁND PDQR GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD VDPSD#LFFKDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁVDQWëUDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDå WLQÁPHQD_XSSDMMDWL NXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁWX VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDåVDQWëUDD FLWWDå__ $ % KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_L##KD VDPPDWHVXFKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁ WDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_ NXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR GKÁWX VDPSD#LFFKDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁVDQWëUDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDN NKD\HYÁFXWë WL QÁPHQD_ FXWL FLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁSD#LVDQGKë WLQÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQDFDXSSDMMDWL NXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå VDQWëUDD FLWWD±__ F HWLLPÁQLD##KDSLDKHWXND YLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ $ % & ' ( ) 9 VUGFLVHG§F>MHGHQ] Y·HXYHGHQ·FK@S §MHPQÕREVD]HQ·FKHVWLHOHPHQW MDNR S HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FY]QLN EODK·Y·VOHGQ·Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQWP\VOL S LM§PQ§QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ@P\VO]NRXPQ§DQHER RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ£@ XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@NWHU£MHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>PRWLYDÇQ§FK@NR HQ SURVW·S §MHPQ·P F§WÕQ§PGRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOL>QD]·YDQ·@P\VO]NRXPQ§ $ % 9 VUGFLVHG§F>MHGHQ] Y·HXYHGHQ·FK@S §MHPQÕREVD]HQ·FKHVWLHOHPHQW MDNR S HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F EODK£PXY·VOHGQ£PXY\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£PXHOHPHQWX P\VOLEH]>PRWLYDÇQ§FK@NR HQNWHU·SURYG§S LM§PQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@ P\VO]NRXPQ§DQHER RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@ DQHER XUÇRYQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD>P\VOL@DQHER S HUXHQ§ NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@]PL]HQ§DQHER ]PL]HQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLN WDN]YDQ£@QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD >DWÕFKWRYHFKRVPMVRXVWDY\P\VOLNWHU£SURYG§@EODK·Y·VOHGQ·NR HQ SURVW· S §MHPQ·PF§WÕQ§PGRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOL>QD]·YDQ·@P\VO]NRXPQ§ $ % & ' ( ) 7ÕFKWRRVPVHQD]·YY·VOHGQ£VWDY\P\VOLEH]NR HQ 1VOHGXM§F§FK RVP EODK·FK Y·VOHGQ·FK VWDY P\VOL MH VSRMHQR V EODKRGUQ·PL PRWLYDÇQ§PL NR HQ\ WÕGURVWL VP§ 14 OLYRVWL D PRXGURVWL -HGQ VH R Y·VOHGN\ NWHU£ MVRX VLFH SDVLYQ§ SURWRH WYR § YQLW Q§ + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD ]NODGQX P\VOL NWHU£ YDN MVRX VRXÇVW§ YÕW§KR NRPSOH[QÕM§KR SURFHVX 0H WR E·W QDS §NODG SURFHVPHGLWDFHYL]ppNWHU·E\OPRWLYRYQRYOLYQÕQDMHHYHQWXOQÕLGOHFKWÕQ7DNRY·WR SURFHV YHGH S §SDGQÕ N S HUXHQ§ NRQWLQXLW\ Y REODVWL VP\VO ]PL]HQ§ ] W£WR REODVWL D QDSRMHQ§ QRY£ NRQWLQXLW\Y PHGLWDÇQ§REODVWLWYDUXYL]p v VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå ±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåVDVDNKÁULNDå WLLPÁQLD##KDSLNÁPÁYDFDUD VDKHWXNDYLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S>P\VOL@ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§FKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·FKWÕQ·W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§FKWÕQ·W\S 7ÕFKWRRVPVHQD]·YY·VOHGQ£VWDY\P\VOLY REODVWLVP\VO VSRMHQ£VNR HQ\ v HNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_L##KD VDPPDQWHVXFKDVX ÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_\DWKÁUDKDå MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDN NKD\HYÁFXWë WL QÁPHQD_ FXWL FLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁSD#LVDQGKë WLQÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQDFDXSSDMMDQWë WL__ $ % & ' 9]QLNDM§MHGLQÕY VUGFLVHG§F>MHGHQ] Y·HXYHGHQ·FK@S §MHPQÕREVD]HQ·FKHVWL HOHPHQW MDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FSRGOHWRKRNG\ RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLN WDN]YDQ£@XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@DQHER XUÇRYQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@ NRQWLQXLWD>P\VOL@DQHER S HUXHQ§NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@]PL]HQ§ DQHER ]PL]HQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§F >Y]QLNWDN]YDQP\VO@NRQWLQXLWD ( $ % & ' ( HYDåDKHWXNÁQLD##KD_VDKHWXNÁQLD##KÁ_ WLVRüDVDNÁPÁYDFDUD NXVDOD YLSÁND FLWWÁQLVDPDWWÁQL__ 7RWRMHRVP>VWDY@EH]NR HQRVPV NR HQ\GRKURPDG\WHG\HVWQFWEODK·FK Y·VOHGQ·FKVWDY P\VOLY REODVWLVP\VORYRVWL 15 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD >5+SD DU+SÁYDFDUDYLSÁND FLWWÁQL 9½VOHGQ©VWDY\YREODVWLPHGLWDFH @ v YLWDNND YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå SD#KDPDMMKÁQD YLSÁND FLWWDå YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå GXWL\DMMKÁQD YLSÁND FLWWDå SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåWDWL\DMMKÁQD YLSÁND FLWWDå VXNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåFDWXWWKDMMKÁQD YLSÁND FLWWDå XSHNNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåSD±FDPDMMKÁQD YLSÁND FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLSD±FD SLU+SÁYDFDUD YLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ HNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_SD#KDYë NDVL ÁGëNDåÁODPELWYÁ_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDN NKD\HYÁFXWë WLQÁPHQD_ FXWL FLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁSD#LVDQGKë WL QÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQDFD XSSDMMDQWL__ $ % & ' ( 3RM§PQ§PUR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ Y·VOHGQP\VOSUYQ§KRSRKURXHQ§ UR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQY·VOHGQ P\VOGUXK£KRSRKURXHQ§ QDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQY·VOHGQ P\VOW HW§KRSRKURXHQ§ WÕVW§PDMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQY·VOHGQ P\VOÇWYUW£KRSRKURXHQ§ Y\URYQDQRVW§DMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQY·VOHGQ P\VOSW£KRSRKURXHQ§ < WÕFKWRSÕWQD]·YPHY·VOHGQ£W\S\P\VOLREODVWLWYDU 9]QLNDM§MHGLQÕY VUGFLVHG§F>MHGHQ] PHGLWDÇQ§FKS HGPÕW@NDVLíRX]HPÕSRǧQDMH MDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FSRGOHWRKRNG\ RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@ XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@DQHER XUÇRYQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD>P\VOL@ DQHER S HUXHQ§NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@]PL]HQ§DQHER ]PL]HQ§ QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ P\VO@NRQWLQXLWD $ % & ' ( v ÁNÁV DQD±F Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå YL±±Á D±F Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå QHYD VD±±Á Q ÁVD±± Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLFDWWÁULDU+SÁYDFDUD YLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ KDGD\DåDQLVVÁ\D_\DWKÁQXSXEELNDå NDVL XJJKÁ#LP ÁNÁVD± FD SD#KDP ÁUXSSD YL±±ÁD±FD QDWWKL EKÁYD±FD ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD±FDÁODPELWYÁ_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDQ WL $ 16 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD QÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDN NKD\HYÁFXWë WLQÁPHQD_ FXWL FLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁ SD#LVDQGKë WLQÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WL QÁPHQDFDXSSDMMDQWL__ % & ' ( 9·VOHGQP\VOREODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLSURVWRUX Y·VOHGQP\VOREODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLYÕGRP§ Y·VOHGQP\VOREODVWLQLFRW\ Y·VOHGQP\VOREODVWLDQL;YQ§PQ§;DQL;QHYQ§PQ§ < WRWRMVRXÇW\ LGUXK\Y·VOHGQ£P\VOLYHWYDUXSURVW£REODVWL 9]QLNDM§Y VUGFLQHVHG§FRGSRY§GDM§F§YL]p SURVWRUSRRGVWUDQÕQ§NDVLí\ ]HPÕ D YÕGRP§SUYQ§KRQHWÕOHVQ£KR>SRKURXHQ§@DQHER QHS §WRPQRVW>S HGPÕWX@DQHER QLFRWXFRE\]NODGQXMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FSRGOHWRKRNG\ RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F >Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@DQHER XUÇRYQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@ NRQWLQXLWD>P\VOL@DQHER S HUXHQ§NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@]PL]HQ§ DQHER ]PL]HQ§QVOHGXM§F>Y]QLNWDN]YDQ£@QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§F >Y]QLNWDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD $ % & ' ( >/RNXWWDUDSKDOD FLWWÁQL 1DGVYÛWVN©W\S\P\VOLSORGX @ v VRWÁSDWWL SKDOD FLWWDå VDNDGDJÁPL SKDOD FLWWDå DQÁJÁPL SKDOD FLWWDå DUDKDWWD SKDOD FLWWD±F HWLLPHVXFDWXVXORNXWWDUD SKDOD FLWWHVXVRWÁSDWWL SKDOD FLWWDå WÁYDPDJJ ÁQDQWDUDåMÁ\DPÁQDåHNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D__ LWDUÁQLWëLSLQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_DYLVHVHQDFDWWÁULSL QLEEÁDPÁODPELWYÁ_SD#KDP XSSDWWL\DåPDJJ ÁQDQWDUDåHYD VX±±DWR YLPRNNKR_ DQLPLWWR YLPRNNKR_ DSSDLKLWWRYLPRNNKR WLQÁPHQDXSSDMMDQWë WL__ $ % & VDPDWWÁQLFDWWÁULSLORNXWWDUD SKDOD FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 0\VOSORGXYVWXSXGRSURXGX P\VOSORGXMHGQRXVHQDYUDFHM§F§KR P\VOSORGXQHQYUDWX P\VOSORGXRSURWÕQ§ < PH]LWÕPLWRÇW\ PLQDGVYÕWVN·PLW\S\P\VOLSORGXMHGLQÕP\VOSORGXYVWXSXGR SURXGXVHG§YG\ Y VUGFLSRNXGQVOHGXMHP\VOLVWH]N\2VWDWQ§W LY VUGFLEXÉVHG§ DQHERQHVHG§YHFKQ\ÇW\ LYDNSRM§PDM§MDNRS HGPÕWQLEEQXDS LSUYQ§PY]QLNXSR VWH]FHVHQD]·YDM§ RVYRER]HQ§SU]GQRWRX RVYRER]HQ§EH]H]QDN RVYRER]HQ§ QHONDYRVW§ $ % & 9HFKQ\ÇW\ LVHQD]·YDM§QDGVYÕWVNP\VOSORGX 17 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD >$NXVDOD YLSÁND FLWWÁQL 1HEODKRG¡UQ©Y½VOHGQ©W\S\P\VOL @ v FDNNK Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DDQL##KD VDPPDWDåU+S Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_ÁORN +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå FDNNKX YL±±ÁDå__ VRW Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DDQL##KD VDPPDWDåVDGG Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_ÁNÁV +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå VRWD YL±±ÁDå__ JKÁ Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DDQL##KD VDPPDWDåJDQGK Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_YÁ\R GKÁW +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåJKÁD YL±±ÁDå__ MLYK Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DDQL##KD VDPPDWDåUDV Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_ XGDN +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁNDåXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå MLYKÁ YL±±ÁDå__ NÁ\ Á\DWDQDåQLVVÁ\DDQL##KD VDPPDWDåSKR##KDEE Á\DWDQDå ÁODPELWYÁ_SD#KDY +SDQLVVD\DåODEKLWYÁPDQR GKÁW ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDPHYDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁNDåGXNNKD VDKDJDWDå NÁ\D YL±±ÁDå__ 1D]NODGQÕ]UDNXVHG§FQHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXWYDUMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F VYÕWORMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOL WDNY]QLNMDNRWR QHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§]UDNX 1D]NODGQÕVOXFKXVHG§FQHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQX]YXNMDNRS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§FSURVWRUMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§ HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDNY]QLNMDNRWRQHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§VOXFKX 1D]NODGQÕÇLFKXVHG§FQHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXSDFKMDNRS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§FY]GXFKMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§ HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDNY]QLNMDNRWRQHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§ÇLFKX 1D]NODGQÕMD]\NXVHG§FQHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXFKX MDNRS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§FYRGXMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§ HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDNY]QLNMDNRWRQHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@Y\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§FKXWL 1D]NODGQÕWÕODVHG§FQHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQRX]NODGQXGRW\NMDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§F ]HPLMDNRVSRXWÕF§SRGP§QNXEHURXFMDNRQVOHGHN]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOLWDN Y]QLNMDNRWRQHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·>VWDY@ QHS §MHPQ·PF§WÕQ§PGRSURY]HQ£YÕGRP§WÕOD 18 +SD +SD 5 $U v 9LEKÁJD KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_SD±FDQQDåDNXVDOD YLSÁND YL±±ÁDP D±±DWDU ÁQDQWDUDå_WDVV HY ÁUDPPDDåJDKHWYÁXSSDMMDWL DNXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå VDPSD#LFFKDQD FLWWDå__ KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_DQL##KD VDPPDWHVXFKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\Då YÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_ DNXVDOD YLSÁND PDQR GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD VDPSD#LFFKDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁVDQWëUDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDå WLQÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDN NKD\HYÁFXWë WLQÁPHQD_ FXWL FLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁ SD#LVDQGKë WLQÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WL QÁPHQDFDXSSDMMDWLDNXVDOD YLSÁN ÁKHWXND PDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåVDQWëUDD FLWWD±F __ $ % & ' ( ) HWLLPÁQLVDWWDSLDNXVDOD YLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 9 VUGFLVHG§FQHEODK·PY·VOHGQ·PW\SPYÕGRP§SÕWL>VP\VO@QVOHGXM§FSUYÕ MHMLFKS HGPÕWEHURXFY]QLNMDNRWRQHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ· HOHPHQWP\VOLEH]NR HQ >QD]·YDQ·@P\VOS LM§PQ§ 9 VUGFLVHG§F>MHGHQ] Y·HXYHGHQ·FK@QHS §MHPQÕREVD]HQ·FKHVWLHOHPHQW MDNR S HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FY]QLN QHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQW P\VOLS LM§PQ§QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ@P\VO]NRXPQ§DQHER RYOLYQÕQ§QVOHGXM§F >WDN]YDQ£@XUÇRYQ§>S HGPÕWX@ XUÇRYQ§QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD>P\VOL@ DQHER S HUXHQ§NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ£@]PL]HQ§DQHER ]PL]HQ§QVOHGXM§F >WDN]YDQ£@QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§F>WDN]YDQ@NRQWLQXLWD >DWÕFKWRYHFKVHGPMVRXVWDY\P\VOLNWHU£SURYG§@QHEODK·Y·VOHGQ·QHXWUOQ§P F§WÕQ§PGRSURY]HQ·HOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOL>QD]·YDQ·@P\VO]NRXPQ§ $ % & ' ( ) 7ÕFKWRVHGPVHQD]·YQHEODK£Y·VOHGQ£VWDY\P\VOLEH]NR HQ >.UL\Á FLWWÁQL)XQNÍQVWDY\P\VOL @ >.ÁPÁYDFDUD NUL\Á FLWWÁQL )XQNÍQVWDY\P\VOLYREODVWLVP\VO/ @ v XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDW ÁKHWXND NUL\Á PDQRGKÁWX SD±FDGYÁU ÁYDMMDQD FLWWDåKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_EKDYDJ ÁQDQWDUDåSD±FDVX ÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_SD±FDQQDåYL±±ÁDå SXUHFÁULNDåKXWYÁXSSDMMDWL__ 9\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·NR HQ SURVW·IXQNÇQ§HOHPHQWP\VOL>NWHU·SURYG§ IXQNFL@]SR]RURYQ§QDSÕWLEUDQFK>VP\VO@VHG§F§Y VUGFLQVOHGXM§F§NRQWLQXLWÕD SRM§PDM§F§MHGHQ] SÕWLS HGPÕWY]QLNS HGFK]HM§FSDWHUXYÕGRP§>VP\VO@ 19 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v NUL\ ÁKHWXND PDQRYL±±ÁDGKÁWX VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD FLWWDå HNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\ _HYDPDQRGYÁUHFKDVXÁUDPPDHVX \DåYÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_DUDKDWRVLWDåNXUXPÁQDå_ PDQRYL±±ÁDGKÁWX ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDåXSSDMMDWL__ .R HQ SURVW·IXQNÇQ§HOHPHQWP\VOLNWHU·MHUDGRVW§GRSURY]HQRXP\VO§MHGLQÕ Y VUGFLVHG§F§DQDEUQÕP\VOLMHGHQ]HHVWLS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§F§DUDKDWRYL´VPÕY Y\YROYDM§F§Y]QLNSR]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPYÕGRP§P\VOL v NUL\ ÁKHWXND PDQRYL±±ÁDGKÁWX XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDåÁYDMMDQD FLWWDåKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ\DWKÁUDKDå_ EKDYDJ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁÁYDMMDQDQ WLQÁPHQD_ VDQWëUD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁ YRWWKDSDQDQ WLQÁPHQD_FKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁWDåYÁ ÁODPELWYÁ_NÁPÁYDFDUD NXVDO DNXVDOÁ NUL\ ÁYDMMDQÁQDå SXUHFÁULNDåKXWYÁXSSDMMDWL__ LPÁQLWëLSLDKHWXND NUL\Á FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ $ % .R HQ SURVW·Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·IXQNÇQ§HOHPHQWYÕGRP§P\VOLMHP\VO§ ]SR]RURYQ§Y VUGFLVHG§F§QHERQHVHG§F§SRGOHWRKR NRQWLQXLWÕQVOHGXM§FQD]·YVH ]SR]RURYQ§DQHER ]NRXPQ§QVOHGXM§FQD]·YVH]MLWÕQ§MHGHQ]HHVWLS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§F§Y]QLNS HGIXQNÇQ§P]SR]RURYQ§PEODKRGUQ£KRQHERQHEODKRGUQ£KR < 7\WRW LpppVHQD]·YDM§IXQNÇQ§VWDY\P\VOLEH]NR HQ $ % v VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå SH VDVDNKÁULNDåNUL\Á FLWWDå VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå SH VDVDNKÁULNDåNUL\Á FLWWDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå SH VDVDNKÁULNDåNUL\Á FLWWDå XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWDå±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDåDVDNKÁULNDå SH VDVDNKÁULNDåNUL\Á FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLD##KDSLVDKHWXNDNUL\Á FLWWÁQLQÁPD__KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D YÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_FKDVXÁUDPPDHVX\DåYÁWDåYÁÁODPELWYÁ_ PDQR YL±±ÁD GKÁWX ÁYDMMDQ ÁQDQWDUDåXSSDMMDWL__ HYDåDKHWXNÁQLWëL_VDKHWXNÁQLD##KÁ_ WLHNÁGDVDNÁPÁYDFDUD NUL\Á FLWWÁQLVDPDWWÁQL__ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S>IXQNÇQ§P\VOL@ G DWSG FKWÕQ·W\SIXQNÇQ§P\VOL UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S G DWSG FKWÕQ·W\SIXQNÇQ§P\VOL Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·V YÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ·VSRQWQQ§W\S G DWSG FKWÕQ·W\SIXQNÇQ§P\VOL Y\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ·EH]YÕGÕQ§VSRQWQQ§W\S G DWSG FKWÕQ·W\SIXQNÇQ§P\VOL 20 +SD 5 +SD $U 9LEKÁJD < WÕFKWRRVPVHQD]·YIXQNÇQ§W\S\P\VOLVNR HQ\9 VUGFLVHG§FQHERQHVHG§FMHGHQ ]HHVWLS HGPÕW SRM§PDM§FY]QLNDM§QVOHGXM§F]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPYÕGRP§P\VOL 7RWRMVRXW L>VWDY\P\VOL@EH]NR HQ DRVPV NR HQ\ GRKURPDG\MHGHQFWIXQNÇQ§FKVWDY P\VOLY REODVWLVP\VO >5+SD DU+SÁYDFDUD NUL\Á FLWWÁQL )XQNÍQVWDY\P\VOLYWÛOHVQ©DQHWÛOHVQ©REODVWL @ v YLWDNND YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå SD#KDPDMMKÁQD NUL\Á FLWWDå YLFÁUD SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDå GXWL\DMMKÁQD NUL\Á FLWWDå SëWL VXNKD FLWW HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåWDWL\DMMKÁQD NUL\Á FLWWDå VXNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåFDWXWWKDMMKÁQD NUL\Á FLWWDå XSHNNK HNDJJDWÁ VDKLWDåSD±FDPDMMKÁQD NUL\Á FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLSD±FD SLU+SÁYDFDUD NUL\Á FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ HNDQWHQDKDGD\DåQLVVÁ\D_SD#KDYë NDVL ÁGëNDåÁODPELWYÁ XSSDMMDQWL __SD±FDPDåSDQDFKDüÁUDPPDDPSLKRWL__ 3RM§PQ§PUR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ IXQNÇQ§P\VOSUYQ§KRSRKURXHQ§ UR]OLRYQ§PQDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ IXQNÇQ§P\VOGUXK£KR SRKURXHQ§ QDGHQ§PWÕVW§PMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQ IXQNÇQ§P\VOW HW§KRSRKURXHQ§ WÕVW§PDMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§P\VOLGRSURY]HQIXQNÇQ§P\VOÇWYUW£KRSRKURXHQ§ Y\URYQDQRVW§DMHGQRYUFKRORYRVW§GRSURY]HQIXQNÇQ§P\VOSW£KRSRKURXHQ§ < WÕFKWRSÕWQD]·YPHIXQNÇQ§VWDY\P\VOLREODVWLWYDU v 9]QLNDM§MHGLQÕY VUGFLVHG§FSRǧQDM§FNDVLíRX]HPÕ >MHGHQ] WDNRY·FKWRPHGLWDÇQ§FK S §SUDYN@MDNRS HGPÕWSRM§PDM§FY SW£P>SRKURXHQ§@MHYDNHVW>PRQ·FKGUXK@ S HGPÕW ÁNÁV DQD±F Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå YL±±Á D±F Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWDå QHYD VD±±Á Q ÁVD±± Á\DWDQD YLSÁND FLWWD± F HWLLPÁQLFDWWÁULDU+SÁYDFDUD YLSÁND FLWWÁQLQÁPD__ 9·VOHGQP\VOY REODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLSURVWRUX Y·VOHGQP\VOY REODVWLQHNRQHÇQRVWLYÕGRP§ Y·VOHGQP\VOYREODVWLQLFRW\ Y·VOHGQP\VOYREODVWLDQL;YQ§PQ§;DQL;QHYQ§PQ§ < WRWRMVRXÇW\ LGUXK\Y·VOHGQ£P\VOLYHWYDUXSURVW£REODVWL 21 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v KDGD\DåQLVVÁ\DYÁDQLVVÁ\DYÁ_\DWKÁQXSXEELNDå NDVL XJJKÁ#LP ÁNÁVD±FD SD#KDP ÁUXSSD YL±±ÁD±FD QDWWKL EKÁYD±FD ÁNL±FD±± Á\DWDQD±FDÁODPELWYÁ_ MDYDQ ÁQDQWDUDåYÁWDG ÁUDPPDDQ WLQÁPHQD_ WDG ÁUDPPD ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQD_ EKDYDJDNNKD\HYÁFXWë WLQÁPHQD_ FXWLFLWW ÁQDQWDUDåYÁSD#LVDQGKë WLQÁPHQD_ SD#LVDQGK ÁQDQWDUDåYÁEKDYDJDQ WLQÁPHQDFDXSSDMMDQWL__ $ % & ' VDPDWWÁQLFDWÁULDU+SÁYDFDUD NUL\ÁFLWWÁQL__ ( 9]QLNDM§Y VUGFLVHG§FQHERQHVHG§FSRGOHS HGFK]HM§F§>P\VOL@ SURVWRUXY]QLNO£RGVWUDQÕQ§PNDVLí\DQHER YÕGRP§SUYQ§KRQHWÕOHVQ£KR>SRKURXHQ§@DQHER QHS §WRPQRVWL>S HGPÕWX@DQHER QLFRW\FRE\]NODGQ\>MHGQR] WÕFKWRÇW\ @MDNRS HGPÕWPDM§F RYOLYïRYQ§QVOHGXM§>DWHKG\@VHMPHQXM§]D]QDPHQQ§S HGPÕWXDQHER ]D]QDPHQQ§S HGPÕWXQVOHGXM§>DWHKG\@VHMPHQXM§NRQWLQXLWDDQHER ]DVWDYHQ§NRQWLQXLW\QVOHGXM§>DWHKG\@VHMPHQXM§S HUXHQ§DQHER S HUXHQ§P\VOLQVOHGXM§>DWHKG\@VHMPHQXM§QDSRMHQ§DQHER QDSRMHQ§QVOHGXM§>DWHKG\@VHMPHQXM§NRQWLQXLWD < 'RKURPDG\W\WRÇW\ LMVRXIXQNÇQ§VWDY\P\VOLQHWÕOHVQ£REODVWL $ % & ' ( v HWWÁYDWÁHNDYëVDWLNXVDOD FLWWÁQL_GYÁGÁVDDNXVDOD FLWWÁQL_ FKDWLåVDYLSÁND FLWWÁQL_YëVDWLNUL\Á FLWWÁQL_ FHWLHN+QDQDYXWLFLWWÁQL__ 7DNWRMHMHGHQDGYDFHW>W\S@EODKRGUQ£P\VOLGYDQFW>W\S@QHEODKRGUQ£P\VOL W LFHWHVW>W\S@Y·VOHGQ£P\VOLGYDFHW>W\S@IXQNÇQ§P\VOL GRKURPDG\WHG\RVPGHVWGHYÕW>W\S@P\VOL FLWWD YLEKÁJRQL##KLWR $QDO·]DP\VOLMHGRNRQÇHQD 22 +SD 5 +SD $U 9LEKÁJD >&(7$6 ,.$9,%+À*$ $QDO½]DVOR>HNP\VOL @ >6DEED FLWWD VÁGKÁUDÁ FHWDVLNÁ 6OR>N\SWRPQ©YHY!HFKVWDYHFK@ v FHWDVLNÁSDQDGYHSD±±ÁVDKRQWL__NDWKDå__ 6ORHNP\VOLMHYDNSDGHVWGYD-DNWR" SKDVVD FHWDQÁ YHGDQÁ HNDJJDWÁ .RQWDNW ]PÕU F§WÕQ§ MHGQRYUFKRORYRVW VD±±Á MëYLWLQGUL\D YQ§PQ§ YLWDOLWD>VFKRSQRVWLYRWD@ PDQDVLNÁUR SR]RUQRVW F HWLVDWW LPHFHWDVLNÁVDEEDFLWWD VÁGKÁUDÁQÁPD__ < WRMHVHGPVORHN>CS §WRPQ·FKY NDG£P\VOLA DWXG§@QD]·YDQ·FKYXG\S §WRPQ£ 7 7 9 GDO§P Y·ÇWX VORHN P\VOL VH WH[W 5 S½U SD 9LEK½JD YÕQXMH QHMSUYH YHP EODKRGUQ·P VORNP 7.DïPD 7 3RGREQÕ MH WRPX Y WH[WHFK NQRQX $QXSDGD 6XWWD 0 'KDPPDVDíJDQß &LWWXSS½GD Y]WDHQ·FK SULPUQÕ QD SUD[L PHGLWDFH 9 SR]GÕML Y]QLNO·FK WH[WHFK MDNR QDS 9LVXGGKL 0DJJD D 7 7 $EKLGKDPPD $WWKD 6DíJDKD MH GYQD S HGQRVW WHRUHWLFN\ V\VWHPDWLFN£PX XVSR GQ§ 3RGOH 7 7 7 WDNRY£KRWR XVSR GQ§ NWHU£ XYG§ SR VORNFK YXG\S §WRPQ·FK VDEED FLWWD V½GK½UDï½ FHWDVLN½ VORN\ S §WRPQ£ S §OHLWRVWQÕ SDNLïïDND VH §G§ L QDH ǧVORYQ§ VORHN P\VOL 7RWR ǧVORYQ§ P XOHKÇLW RULHQWDFL Y QD§ WDEXOFH Y·VN\WX MHGQRWOLY·FK VORHN Y U]Q·FK W\SHFK P\VOL YL] GRGDWHN 3 §OHLWRVWQ£VORN\P\VOLSDNLïïDNDpDQVOHGXM§F§NWHU£VHY\VN\WXM§Y QÕNWHU·FKEODKRGUQ·FK YLWDNND pojímání YLFÁUD rozlišování DGKLPRNNKD rozhodnutí YLUL\D úsilí QHXWUOQ§FKL]KRXEQ·FKVWDYHFKP\VOLMVRXW\WR >.XVDOD FHWDVLNÁ %ODKRG¡UQ©VOR>N\P\VOL @ v VDGGK LQGUL\Då VFKRSQRVWGYÕU\ VDW LQGU\Då VFKRSQRVWY§PDYRVWL SD±± LQGU\Då VFKRSQRVWPRXGURVWL DGRVR SëWL nadšení FKDQGD SiQt KLUL EDODå V§ODVWXGX RWWDSD EDODå V§ODRKOHGXSOQRVWL DOREKR WÕGURVWS HNRQQ§FKWLYRVWL VP§ OLYRVWS HNRQQ§QHQYLVWL 1D §]HQ§ SURFHV P\VOL VH SRG§O§ GYDDGYDFHW §G§F§FK VFKRSQRVW§ LQGUL\D ] WRKR MH RVP WÕOHVQ·FK 7 YL] p D SÕW VORN\ ǧVOR §G§F§FK FHONRYRX CVFKRSQRVW P\VOA PDQR LQGUL\D ÿ§G§F§ VFKRSQRVWL MVRX Y\VYÕWOHQ\ Y XÇHEQLFL )U·ED 3V\FKRORJLH ]YOGQ© LYRWD 7 $SOLNDFH PHWRG\ DEKLGKDPPD%UQRNDSLWRODY·ÇHWYHFK §G§F§FKVFKRSQRVW§MHWDPW£Y 'RGDWNX$ 23 v NÁ\D SDVVDGGKL %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD ]NOLGQÕQ§VHVWDY\>YHFKVORHN@ FLWWD SDVVDGGKL ]NOLGQÕQ§P\VOL NÁ\D ODKXWÁ PUWQRVWP\VOL FLWWD SÁJX±±DWÁ SRK\EOLYRVWP\VOL ]NXHQRVWP\VOL NÁ\ XMMXNDWÁ SRGGDMQRVWVHVWDY\ FLWWD PXGXWÁ FLWWD NDPPD±±DWÁ ]NXHQRVWVHVWDY\ NÁ\D PXGXWÁ PUWQRVWVHVWDY\ NÁ\D SÁJX±±DWÁ SRK\EOLYRVWVHVWDY\ FLWWD ODKXWÁ NÁ\D NDPPD±±DWÁ S §PRVWVHVWDY\ FLWW XMMXNDWÁ SRGGDMQRVWP\VOL S §PRVWP\VOL WDWUDPDMMKDWWDWÁ Y\YHQRVWYHFK>VORHNP\VOL@ F HWLLPHYëVDWLFHWDVLNÁDNXVDODFLWWHVXFHYDDKHWXNDFLWWHVXFÁWL VDPDWLåVDFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQW HYD__ < WÕFKWRFHONHPGYDFHWVORHN>; @QHY]QLNYHW LFHWLVWDYHFKP\VOLNWHU£MVRX ]KRXEQ£QHEREH]NR HQ v SD±±Á SDQDGYÁGDVDVX±ÁDYLSSD\XWWHVXSLQDODEEKDWL_ WDVPÁ GYÁFDWWÁüLVDFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDWL__ 0RXGURVWYDNQDY§FQHQ§YHGYDQFWL>VWDYHFKP\VOL@EH]YÕGÕQ§WDNHQHY]QLNYH ÇW\ LFHWLGYRXVWDYHFKP\VOL v NDUXÁ PXGLWÁ SDQDSD±FDPDMMKÁQD YDMMLWD U+SDYDFDUD FLWWHVX_VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD NÁPÁYDFDUD NXVDODFLWWHVX_ VDKHWXND VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD NUL\ÁFLWWHVX_ FÁWLVDPDYëVDWL FLWWHVXNDGÁFLXSSDMMDQWLYLVXåYLVXå__ 6RXFLWDVSROXUDGRVWYDNY]QLNDM§Y P\VOLREODVWLWYDU Y\M§PDMHSW£SRKURXHQ§>GOH W£@Y EODKRGUQ£UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ£P\VOLREODVWLVP\VO>GOH@Y QHXWUOQÕIXQNÇQ§ UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ£P\VOLV NR HQ\ < Y]QLNDM§WHG\QÕNG\YHGYDFHWLVWDYHFKP\VOLDOHYG\RGGÕOHQÕ]YO 7DN]YDQ£ QH]PÕUQ£ DSSDPD½ VWDY\ Y]QHHQ£KR SRE·YQ§ EUDKPD7YLK½UD MVRX ÇW\ L PHWW QHEROLGREURWLYRVWMHGOHDEKLGKDPP\LGHQWLFNVHVP§ OLYRVW§DGRVD ;YL]WDEXONDY GRGDWNXVORND ǧVORp NDUXï½QHEROLVRXFLWPXGLW½QHEROLVG§OHQUDGRVW XSHNNK½QHEROLY\URYQDQRVW ÇLSRY]QHVHQQH]YLVORVWMH]GHXYHGHQDMDNRY\YHQRVWWDWUDPDMMKDWWDW½ ;VORNDǧVORp v VDPPÁ YÁFÁ VDPPÁ NDPPDQWR VDPPÁ ÁMëYR FD ORNXWWDUD FLWWHVXXSSDMMDQW HYD__ORNL\D FLWWHVXSDQDNÁPÁYDFDUD NXVDOD FLWWHVX\HYDNDGÁFLQÁQÁKXWYÁXSSDMMDQWL__ 3UDYPOXYDSUDY£MHGQQ§DSUDY·VW\OLYRWDY]QLNDM§Y QDGVYÕWVN£P\VOL9HVYÕWVN£ P\VOLYDNW£ QÕNG\Y]QLNDM§DWRVLFHSRU]QXY EODKRGUQ£P\VOLREODVWLVP\VO 24 + + 5 SD $U SD 9LEKÁJD >3DNLDND FHWDVLNÁ 6OR>N\Y\VN\WXMFVHSOH>LWRVWQÛ@ v YLWDNNR YLFÁUR SëWL YLUL\LQGUL\Då FKDQGR DGKLPRNNKR FHWLFKDVXSDNLDND FHWDVLNHVX__YLWDND YLFÁUÁWÁYDGYLSD±FD YL±±ÁHVXFHYDXSDULPHVXWëVXU+SÁYDFDUD FLWWHVXFDVDEE ÁU+SD FLWWHVXFÁ_WLHNDWLåVDFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQWL__ 3RM§PQ§UR]OLRYQ§QDGHQ§´VLO§S Q§DUR]KRGQXW§< WRMHHVWS §OHLWRVWQÕVH Y\VN\WXM§F§FKVORHN3RM§PQ§DUR]OLRYQ§VHQHY\VN\WXMHYHGYRXSÕWLF§FKYÕGRP§ VP\VO DQLYHW HFKQHMY\§FKW\SHFKP\VOLREODVWLWYDUXDQLYHYHFKW\SHFKP\VOL WYDUXSURVW£REODVWLQHY]QLNDM§Y MHGQDW LFHWLW\SHFKP\VOL v SëWL SDQDGRPDQDVV XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD FLWWHVXFHYDNÁ\D YL±±ÁHVXFDFDWXWWKDMMKÁQD PDQRGYÁU ÁYDMMDQD FLWWHVXFÁWL_ FDWXSD±±ÁVDFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQWL__ 1DGHQ§YDN>QHQ§S §WRPQR@Y P\VOLGRSURY]HQ£VPXWNHPQHERY\URYQDQRVW§YH YÕGRP§WÕODDYH]SR]RURYQ§QDEUQÕP\VOLS LÇWYUW£PSRKURXHQ§QHY]QLNWHG\ Y SDGHVWLÇW\ HFKW\SHFKP\VOL v YLUL\Då DKHWXND YLSÁNHVXFHYDPDQRGKÁW ÁYDMMDQHVXFÁWL_ VRüDVD FLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQWL__ VLO§>QHQ§Y W\SHFKP\VOL@Y·VOHGQ£EH]NR HQ DYH]SR]RURYQ§HOHPHQWHPP\VOL QHY]QLNY HVWQFWLW\SHFKP\VOL v FKDQGR GYLSD±FDYL±±ÁD PDQRGKÁWXWWLND VDQWëUDD KDVDQD YR##KDEEÁQDåYDVHQDD##KÁUDVDVXDKHWXND FLWWHVX_FHYDGYëVX PRP+KD FLWWHVXFÁWL_VDPDYëVDWLFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQWL__ 3 Q§>QHQ§@Y RVPQFWLW\SHFKP\VOLEH]NR HQÇOHQÕQ·FKGRGYRXSÕWLFYÕGRP§ VP\VOWURMLFHHOHPHQWXP\VOL]NRXPQ§´VPÕYX]MLWÕQ§GOH>QHQ§@YHGYRXW\SHFK ]DVOHSHQ£P\VOLQHY]QLNFHONHPYH GYDFHWLW\SHFKP\VOL v DGKLPRNNKR GYLSD±FD YL±±ÁHVXFHYDYLFLNLFFKÁ FLWWHFÁWL_ HNÁGDVDVXFLWWHVXQXSSDMMDQWL__ 5R]KRGQXW§>QHQ§@YHGYRXSÕWLF§FKYÕGRP§VP\VO DY SRFK\ERYDÇQ£ P\VOLQHY]QLN Y MHGHQFWLW\SHFKP\VOL >$NXVDOD FHWDVLNÁ 1HEODKRG¡UQ©VOR>N\P\VOL @ v LPHHNDQWHQDDNXVDOD FHWDVLNÁYHGLWDEEÁ_PRKR DKLULNDå DQRWWDSSDå XGGKDFFDå WL_FDWWÁURFHWDVLNÁVDEE ÁNXVDOD VÁGKÁUDÁ__ -HGLQÕQVOHGXM§F§QHEODKRGUQ£VORN\P\VOL]DVOHSHQRVWQHVW\GDWRVWEH]RKOHGQRVW QHNOLGMVRXÇW\ LVORN\S §WRPQ£YHYHFKQHEODKRGUQ·FK>VWDYHFKP\VOL@ v OREKR D##KDVXOREKD VDKDJDWD FLWWHVX\HYDXSSDMMDWL__ &KWLYRVWY]QLNY RVPLVWDYHFK>R]QDÇRYDQ·FKMDNR@FKWLYRVW§GRSURY]HQ£VWDY\P\VOL 25 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD v GL##KL PÁQR WKëQD FDWXVXGL##KL JDWD VDPSD\XWWD FLWWHVX\HYDXSSDMMMDWL__ NDGÁFLGL##KL JDWD YLSSD\XWWHVX\HYDXSSDMMMDWL__ PLGGKDå SD±FDVXVDVDNKÁULND FLWWHVX\HYDXSSDMMMDWL__ v GRVR GYëVXSD#LJKD FLWWHVX\HYDXSSDMMMDWL__ =DXMDWRVWY]QLNYH ÇW\ HFK>R]QDÇRYDQ·FKMDNR@VH]DXMDWRVW§VSRMHQ£VWDY\P\VOL 'RP·OLYRVWY]QLNQÕNG\YHÇW\ HFKVWDYHFKEH]]DXMDWRVWLp 6WUQXORVWDPDOWQRVWY]QLNY SÕWLFKWÕQ·FKVWDYHFKP\VOLpp 1HQYLVWY]QLNYHGYRX>R]QDÇRYDQ·FKMDNR@VQHQYLVW§VSRMHQ£VWDY\P\VOL v LVVÁ PDFFKHUD NXNNXFFÁQL GYëVXGRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD FLWWHVX\HYDNDGÁFLXSSDMMDQWLYLVXåYLVXå__ =YLVWODNRPRVWVWDURVW< Y]QLNDM§QÕNG\YHGYRXVWDYHFKP\VOLGRSURY]HQ·FK VPXWNHPDOHYG\RGGÕOHQÕ]YO v YLFLNLFFKÁ YLFLNLFFKÁ VDKDJDWH\HYDXSSDMMMDWL__ 3RFK\ERYDÇQRVWY]QLNYWÕFK>R]QDÇRYDQ·FKMDNR@SRFK\ERYDÇQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£ HYDåVDEEDWKÁSLVDNKHSHQDGYHSD±±ÁVDFHWDVLNÁYHGLWDEEÁWL__ 7DNWRVHPFKSDWY VRXKUQXYHFKSDGHVWGYDVORHNP\VOL >&HWDVLND 6DPSD\RJD 6RXKUDVOR>HNP\VOL @ v GYLSD±FD YL±±ÁHVXVDWW HYDFHWDVLNÁEKDYDQWL_PDQRGKÁWXWWLND DKHWXND SD#LVDQGKL \XJDOHVXGDVD__VRPDQDVVD VDQWëUDD YRWWKDSDQHVXHNDGÁVD_ KDVDQD FLWWHGYÁGDVD__ 9HGYRXVNXSLQFKYÕGRP§SÕWL>VP\VO DMHMLFKS HGPÕW@QDVWYYG\VHGPVORHN P\VOLYL]pVDEED;FLWWD;V»GK»UDí»;FHWDVLN»3RGHVHWL>VORNFKP\VOLWHG\QDY§F V YLWDNNDYLF»UD DDGKLPRNNKDXYHGHQ·PLYp@QDVWYYHW HFKHOHPHQWHFKP\VOL SURYDQ·FKGRQDSRMHQ§YL]p;p9 UDGRVWQ£P]NRXPQ§D]MLWÕQ§MH>V YLUL\D QDY§F@MHGHQFWDY ´VPÕYQ£P\VOL>VSÝWLQDY§F@GYDQFWVORHN P\VOL =DW§PFRY S HGFKR]§SRGNDSLWROH &HWDVLND79LEK½JD E\O\VORN\P\VOLXYHGHQ\Y SR DG§GHILQRYDQ£P MHMLFKY·VN\WHPY MHGQRWOLY·FKVWDYHFKMVRX]GHY·FKRGLVNHPVWDY\DSURMHMLFKFKDUDNWHUL]RYQ§MVRX XYGÕQ\SRÇW\VORHNNWHU£VHY QLFKY\VN\WXM§ v DNXVDOHVXPRP+KDFLWWHVXGYëVXSDDUDVD_SD±FDPD VDWWDPD QDYDPHVXD##KÁUDVD_SD#KDPD WDWL\HVXHN+QDYëVDWL_FK D##KDPD GDVDPHVXYëVDWL_GXWL\D FDWXWWKHVXSDQDFLWWHVXHNDYëVDWL__ 9 QHEODKRGUQ·FKVWDYHFKP\VOL]DVOHSHQ£MHSDWQFW>VORHNWMVHGPVDEED;FLWWD; V»GK»UDí»;FHWDVLN»DN WRPXYLUL\DPRKDDKLULNDDQRWWDSSDXGGKDFFD@Y SW£P VHGP£PDGHYW£PMHMLFK>VOREKDDGDO§PL@RVPQFWY SUYQ§PDW HW§PGHYDWHQFW Y HVW£PRVP£PDGHVW£PGYDFHWYHGUXK£PDÇWYUW£P>DNXVDODVWDYX@P\VOLMHMLFK GYDFHWMHGQDp;p 26 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD v U+SÁYDFDUD SD±FDPHVXDU+SHVXFDWLåVDWL__XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD ±ÁD YLSSD\XWWD FLWWHVXYLSÁND NUL\Á FLWWHVXFHYDFDWXWWKDMMKÁQH FDHNDWLåVDWL_XSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD ±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDYLSÁND NUL\ÁVXFHYDXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD ±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDNXVDOHFD VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD ±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDYLSÁNHFDWDWL\DMMKÁQHFD GYDWWLåVD_VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD ±ÁD YLSSD\XWWDYLSÁND NXVDOD NUL\ÁVXFHYDXSHNNKÁ VDKDJDWD ±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDNXVDOHFD VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD ±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDYLSÁNHFDGXWL\DMMKÁQHFD WHWWLåVD_VRPDQDVVD VDKDJDWD ±ÁD VDPSD\XWWDNXVDOD NUL\ÁVX FHYDSD#KDPDMMKÁQHFDFDWXWWLåVD__ 9H >VWDYXP\VOL@SW£KR>SRKURXHQ§@YREODVWLWYDU DY >REODVWHFK@WYDUXSURVW·FKMH W LFHW>VORHNP\VOL@9HY\URYQDQRVW§GRSURY]HQ£P\VOLEH]YÕGÕQ§EXÉY·VOHGQ£ QHERIXQNÇQ§DYHÇWYUW£PSRKURXHQ§MHW LFHWMHGQD>VORHNP\VOL@YHY\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£VYÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ£P\VOLEXÉY·VOHGQ£QHERIXQNÇQ§DYHY\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£EODKRGUQ£P\VOLEH]YÕGÕQ§MDNR LY UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ£Y·VOHGQ£ P\VOLEH]YÕGÕQ§DYHW HW§PSRKURXHQ§MHMLFKW LFHWGYDY UDGRVW§GRSURY]HQ£EXÉ Y·VOHGQ£EODKRGUQ£QHERIXQNÇQ§P\VOLEH]YÕGÕQ§MDNR LYHY\URYQDQRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£VYÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ£EODKRGUQ£P\VOLDYHY·VOHGQ£ P\VOLUDGRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£VYÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ£DYHGUXK£PSRKURXHQ§MHMLFKW LFHWW LYUDGRVW§ GRSURY]HQ£VYÕGÕQ§PVSRMHQ£EXÉEODKRGUQ£QHERIXQNÇQ§P\VOLDY SUYQ§P SRKURXHQ§MHW LFHWÇW\ L>VORHNP\VOL@ v DSSDPD±±Á YLUDWL\RSDQDHNDWRMÁ\DQWL__ORNXWWDUD FLWWHVXSDQD FKDWWLåVDFHWDVLNÁEKDYDQWL__ 1H]PÕUQ£>VWDY\Y]QHHQ£KRSRE·YQ§EUDKPD;YLK»UD@D]GURYQ§VH>]KRXEQ·FK ]SVRE LW§MHGQQ§DPOXYHQ§@Y]QLNDM§VSROXQDMHGQRXpp9 QDGVYÕWVN·FK VWDYHFKQDVWYW LFHWÇW\ LVORHNP\VOLppp 3RÇW\VORHNY\VN\WXM§F§FKVHY MHGQRWOLY·FKVWDYHFKP\VOLVORX§MDNRPQHPRWHFKQLFNSRPFNDSUR Y\EDYHQ§VLNWHU£VORN\MVRXNRQNU£WQÕYHNWHU£PVWDYXP\VOLS §WRPQ\-HGQ§P]´ÇHOMH]GHW§PWR SRVWXSHP WHVWRYDW YÕGÕQ§ R NWHU£ VORN\ P\VOL VH MHGQ < D SURWR E\ E\OR GRSOïRYQ§ WÕFKWR VORHN Y ]YRUNFK GR S HNODGX YODVWQÕ ]QHKRGQRFHQ§P WH[WX FRE\ QVWURMH Y·XN\ 3UR NRQWUROX VSUYQRVWL Y\EDYRYQ§VHY GRGDWNXQDO£]DM§WDEXON\ 3 L GDO§P SRNURÇLO£P VWXGLX VRXYLVORVW§ PH]L MHY\ MVRX VDPR] HMPÕ W§P QHMGOHLWÕM§P ]GURMHP NDQRQLFN£WH[W\ $EKLGKDPPD73LDN\S HGHY§P'KDPPDVDíJDïßD3DK½QDMHMVRXNRPSRQRYQ\ SURSRX§YQ§YHY]WDKXN PHGLWDÇQ§]NXHQRVWL7RVDP£VHQHG §FLRSR]GÕMLY]QLNO·FKVRXKUQQ·FK WH[WHFK MPHQRYLWÕ R WHRUHWLFN·FK NDSLWROFK 7KHURX %XGGKDJKRVRX Y SW£P VWROHW§ HYURSVN£KR OHWRSRÇWX VHSVDQ£ 9LVXGGKL70DJJD NWHU MH MLQDN RYHP WRX QHMOHS§ S §UXÇNRX XÇLWHO 'KDPP\ 5RYQÕ VRXKUQ Y·]QDP DWWKD YHFK PDWLF 'KDPP\ NWHU· E\O Y MHGHQFW£P VWROHW§ QD SRGNODGÕ 9LVXGGKL70DJJD V\VWHPDWLFN\ SURYHGHQ Y S §UXÇFH $EKLGKDPPD7$WWKD76DíJDKD 7KHU\ $QXUXGGK\ YHGH VS§ N SURFYLÇRYQ§ SDPÕWL QD ´URYQL VORY 3 L VURYQQ§ WH[W $EKLGKDPPD7$WWKD76DíJDKD D $EKLGKDPPD76DíJDKD7*DQWKD ]MLVW§PH EU]\ H QÕNWHU SUR SUD[L PHGLWDFH GOHLW SRXÇHQ§ < QDS §NODGRW]N\QVOHGQRVWLY]QLNQ§VWDYP\VOLDMHMLFKWÕOHVQ£KRRKQLVNDCVHG§FY VUGFLAKDGD\DÙ QLVV½\D<VH]WUF§Y SR]GÕMLVHSVDQ·FKS §UXÇNFK]DPQRVWY§PY]WDKPH]LSRMP\ %ÕKHPY§FHQHW LFHWLOHWY·XN\DVXSHUYL]HSRNURÇLO£PHGLWDFHVHPQÕWH[W$EKLGKDPPD76DíJDKD7 *DQWKD W£WR KLVWRULFN\ < DOH L GLGDNWLFN\ < YEHF SUYQ§ NQLK\ DEKLGKDPPLFN£ OLWHUDWXU\ Y SUD[L YG\RVYÕGÇLO 27 %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD >1,%%À1$ä &O @ v DFFXWDåDPDWDåNKHPDåQLFFDåVDQWDåDVDNKDWDå_ YÁDWëWRWDWKÁJDWRQLEEÁDPWLSDNLWWD\ë__ 1HNRQHÇQQHVPUWHOQEH]SHÇQVWONOLGQQHVWYR HQ VORY\QHSRSVDWHOQMH1LEE»QDNWHURX 'RNRQDO·VNYÕOHXN]DO >*DQWKDNDWWX VDQGDVVDQD $XWRUVN©SRXN¡]¡Q @ v DQHQDSX±±HQDWX%XGGKDGDWWR_YLKÁUD VDåVÁUD EKD\ÁVXPXWWR_ PDKÁPDKDåUÁJD YLQRGDQDåVLYDåDQÁVDYDåNKLSSDPHYÁWL__ $XWRUX%XGGKDGDWWRYLEXGL ]VOXKRXW£WRSUFH XPRQÕQRVQDGQÕML]§VNDWRGW£KU]\VYRERGX M§ MVRXYQÕVDPVU\D]QLFKWHG\XQLNQRXWEOD]H U\FKOHW§PSURWLYHPYOLYPGRVKQRXWMLVWRWX U+SD DU+SD YLEKÁJRQL##KLWR__ $QDO·]DWÕOHVQ£KRDQHWÕOHVQ£KRMHGRNRQÇHQD f%KLNNKX.XVDODºQDQGD 'KDPPUPD%UQR <[email protected]> <[email protected]> 28 + +SD 5 SD $U 9LEKÁJD VORåN\ mysli SKDVVD NRQWDNW YHGDQ» VD««» F§WÕQ§ YQ§PQ§ FHWDQ» ]PÕU FLWWHNDJJDW» MHGQRYUFKRORYRVW MÝYLWLQGUL\D YLWDOLWD PDQDVLN»UR SR]RUQRVW YLWDNND SRM§PQ§ YLF»UD UR]OLRYQ§ DGKLPRNNKD UR]KRGQXW§ YLUL\D ´VLO§ SÝWL QDGHQ§ FKDQGD S Q§ VDGGK» GYÕUD VDWL Y§PDYRVW KLUL VWXG RWWDSD RKOHGXSOQRVW DOREKDG»QD WÕGURVW DGRVDPHWW» VP§ OLYRVW N»\DSDVVDGGKL ]NOLGQÕQ§VHVWDY\ FLWWDSDVVDGGKL ]NOLGQÕQ§P\VOL N»\DODKXW»VHVWDY\ SRK\EOLYRVW FLWWDODKXW» SRK\EOLYRVWP\VOL N»\DPXGXW» SRGGDMQRVWVHVWDY\ FLWWDPXGXW» SRGGDMQRVWP\VOL N»\DNDPPD««DW» PUWQRVWVHVWDY\ YêVN\WVORåHNYMHGQRWOLYêFKVWDYHFKP\VOL FLWWDNDPPD««DW» PUWQRVWP\VOL FLWWD FHWDVLNÁ WH[Wp N»\DS»JX««DW» ]NXHQRVWVHVWDY\ FMJYZPFHNYYF FLWWDS»JX««DW» ]NXHQRVWP\VOL N»\XMMXNDW» S §PRVWVHVWDY\ FLWWXMMXNDW» GYLSD«FDYL««»íD p YÕGRP§SÕWLVP\VO p VDPSD LFFKDQD p S LM§PQ§ p VDQWÝUDíD p ]NRXPQ§ p S §PRVWP\VOL WDWUDPDMMKDWWDW» Y\YHQRVWYHKR NDUXí» VRXFLW PXGLW» VSROXUDGRVW »YDMMDQDSD«FDGY»UD ; ; ;W£ p ; ]SR]RURYQ§YHVP\VOHFK »YDMMDQDPDQRGY»UD p ; p ; p ;W£ ]SR]RURYQ§YP\VOL SD««» PRXGURVW KDVDQD;FLWWD´VPÕY VDPP»;Y»F» SUDYPOXYD VDPP»;NDPPDQWD SUDY£MHGQQ§ PZXFQFHNYYF VRPDQDVVD; XSHNNK» ; EH]W£ MK»QD ; VDPP»;»MÝYD SUDY·VW\OLYRWD PRKD ]DVOHSHQRVW p SRVWXSQÕ; EH] »UXSSD ;; p DKLULND QHVW\GDWRVW ORNXWWDUDYL]MK»QD p ;EH] DQRWWDSSD EH]RKOHGQRVW XGGKDFFD FPZXFQFHNYYF OREKD p ;; SD LJKD p ;; PRPKD p ;; QHSRNRM OREKD FKWLYRVW GL KL ]DXMDWRVW P»QD GRP·OLYRVW [NU¾PFHNYYF N»P»YDFDUDp ; WKÝQD VWUQXORVW PLGGKD PDOWQRVW GRVDSD LJKD QHQYLVW MK»QD YL]MDNRNXVDOD p YL]MDNRDNXVDOD p ; SRVWXSQÕ; YMDNRY·HEH] »UXSSD p YL]MDNRY·H ORNXWWDUD p YL]MDNRY·H LVV» ]YLVW PDFFKHUD PWN^¾ HNYYF DKHWXND p ; YY·HSRGUREQÕ VDKHWXND p ;EH] MK»QD p ; ;YL]NXVDOD ODNRPRVW NXNNXFFD VWDURVW YLFLNLFFK» SRFK\ERYDÇQRVW 29 PZXFQF)HNYY¾SN EODKRGUQ£Q£VWDY\P\VOL [NU¾PF)HNYY¾SN Y·VOHGQ£VWDY\P\VOL US»YDFDUD REODVWWYDU DUS»YDFDUD WYDUXSURVWREODVW ORNXWWDUDSKDODFLWWD QDGVYÕWVNP\VOSORGX o o o o o o US»YDFDUD REODVWWYDU o DUS»YDFDUD WYDUXSURVWREODVW o ORNXWWDUDPDJJDFLWWD QDGVYÕWVNP\VOVWH]N\ o FPZXFQF)HNYY¾SN QHEODKRGUQ£Q£VWDY\P\VOL MFXFSF)HNYYF P\VOSRXK£KR´VPÕYX 30 XUÇRYQ§ o o o o < o N»P»YDFDUD REODVWVP\VO PWN^F)HNYY¾SN QHXWUOQ§IXQNÇQ§VWDY\P\VOL YFI¾QFRGFêF RYOLYQÕQ§ OF[FSF < ]MLWÕQ§ < [TYYMFUFSF ]NRXPQ§ < S LM§PQ§ < YÕGRP§SÕWLVP\VO < o XFSYÚWFêF N»P»YDFDUD REODVWVP\VO XFRUFNHHMFSF Y QLFKY\VN\WXM UF®HF[N®®¾êF DVWDY\P\VOLNWHU©VH ]SR]RURYQ§ VW¡GLFKSURFHVXP\VOL < IXQNFHYÛGRPY GHVHWL ¾[FOOFSF YL±±ÁD NLFFD UFNXFSIMN)GMF[FèLF)HZYN)HNYYF QDSRMHQ§NRQWLQXLWD]PL]HQ§>NRQWLQXLW\@P\VOL %KLNNKX.XVDODÀQDQGD o o o o o
Podobné dokumenty
Jak d leĺitá je znalost Páli?
1HSHGSRNOiGiPåHVHNG\EXGXXþLWJUDPDWLNXNY$OLVWUXNWXHMD]\ND.G\åGHQQ UHFLWXMHPHþW\LSDWLVDPEKLGiXYGRPXMLVLY]WDKPH]LYê]QDP\DWWKiMHY\GKDPPi MHMLFKVRXYLVORVWPL]DNyGRYDQêPL...
Více